Yesterday, as word spread that the FDA banned candy-flavored tobacco
, policy experts cheered the news and cigarette makers condemned it. About what you'd expect. Rather than rehash the standard fare, the Atlantic Wire went beyond the usual commentators to find the folks directly impacted--those who actually smoke strawberry cigarettes (or have moms who do). Here's who cares and what they think:
The Angry Mom
A woman at CafeMom
, a social networking site for (yep) moms, thinks the government should mind its own business: "I think the government needs to butt out, no pun intended. It's our responsibility to care for our health and not smoke, not theirs. Are they going to stop selling yummy flavored soda?"
The kids at Rocky Mountain College's student newspaper
are fuming. In a staff editorial, they write, "What's next if we keep protecting 'the children?' We already see a tax on soda proposed in Congress. We assume Lucky Charms and fast food are next on the chopping block. Since these products can, perhaps, lead children into unhealthy lifestyles, we better ban them just to be safe, right?"
The Condescending Manhattanite Hamilton Nolan
at Gawker lashed out at anyone who'd even think
about smoking flavored tobacco:
Suck down the last sickly sweet puffs of your precious Warm Winter Toffee Camels, kids, because as of today, flavored cigarettes are illegal in America... Tobacco is nasty. It's supposed to be nasty. It is not supposed to taste like various flavors of pie. "Flavored tobacoo" is for hookah smokers who spend all day lounging around cafes rather than blazing trails and building railroads and slaughtering native populations.
The Jones'ing Libertarian
From the rooftops of Rational Review (the "premier libertarian web journal"), Ayn R. Key
recalls the good old days: "Back when I was a smoker, I considered clove cigarettes to be a rare and special treat that I would indulge in once a month. Those things had a flavor that cannot be believed (if you're a smoker). This is ... unbelievable, even for someone who always expects the worst of government."
The Misguided Daughter
Defending her pipe-smoking mother, LokisMama
, writes "My mom smokes cherry tobacco in her pipe. They need to butt the hell out. I smoked for awhile, and frankly, I don't blame people for wanting to smoke flavored cigarettes, because the Marlboro's [sic] I smoked were downright nasty. Menthols are better but not by much."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
jhudson at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.