The idea of an economically significant gas tax is beloved by environmentalists and economists alike. There's just one problem: it's very
But could the oil spill in the Gulf revive support for this
controversial measure? A lot of commentators think it ought to, and
several are frustrated at President Obama for not bringing it up. Here's
the case for raising the gas tax from liberals, conservatives, journalists, and
- Economists for the Gas Tax In a New York Times
article more specifically against the soda tax, Harvard economist and
Bush-era chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers Greg Mankiw
covered the much stronger case for the gas tax: "Whenever you go out
for a drive, you are to some degree committing an antisocial act." You
add to congestion, the likelihood of accidents, pollution, and
contribute to global warming. These are known in economics lingo as the
"negative externalities" of driving.
Many economists advocate
gasoline taxes so that drivers will internalize these negative
externalities. That is, by raising the price of gasoline, a tax would
induce consumers to take into account the harm they cause after making
their purchases. One prominent study added up all the externalities
associated with driving and concluded that the optimal gasoline tax is
over $2 a gallon, about five times the current level (combining the
federal and a typical state's levies) and about the tax rate in many
- So Obvious, So Frustratingly Slow to Gain Traction The Economist's Ryan Avent,
writing at his personal blog, says that he's "just about given up on
the idea that an increase in the gas tax is possible. The Gulf of
Mexico is filling up with oil, and no one in Washington is even
mumbling under his or her breath that maybe now is a good time to think
about an increase." Nevertheless, he says this is the ultimate "easy
answer ... You tax gas, you reduce consumption, and you raise the money
to once-again provide the country with a first-class transportation
system." Would Americans really revolt? He wonders--they're now
"increasingly used" to higher gas prices, "and they hate oil companies
and oil spills and the dastardly foreign companies who sell us oil."
- 'Help with the Oil-Weaning Process' The Christian Science Monitor's Francine Kiefer
tells President Obama that "if he needs cover, he's got it from an
unusual source, Thomas Donohue, leader of the US Chamber of Commerce."
Donahue supports the tax as an equivalent of a "'user fee ... If you
don't drive on the road you don't use it."
- Even the Chamber of Commerce Is for It "The oft-repeated absurdity is this," writes Time's Barbara Kiviat:
"the federal gas tax hasn't changed since 1993 ... Taking inflation out
of the equation, the effective tax has gone down to 12.2 cents a
gallon." Meanwhile, roads are suffering and The Highway Trust Fund "is
practically bankrupt." The U.S. Chamber of Commerce is "not exactly a
pro-tax group," she points out, but they're "clamoring for an increase
... since roads are so important to companies shipping goods and
supplies ... "
- It Could Reduce the Deficit The Atlantic's Derek Thompson
interviews Brookings's William Gale, asking him what a "deficit-busting
plan" might look like. Gale responds that "the main thing right now is
big visible cuts to show that there are no sacred cows. One easy way is
to increase the gas tax. Each dollar of gas tax raises a GDP percentage
point in revenue."
- The Right Way Forward: 'If This Isn't Hitting Bottom, What Is?' Andrew Sullivan says Obama needs to do "much more" to promote such measures. "The way to seize this moment is not to attempt to control what
you cannot--the gush of oil from the open wound in the floor of the
Gulf. It is to remind people of the lax regulation that allowed this to
happen ... and to make the case more passionately than ever that we
need a strategy to get off our oil addiction."
- A Conservative Case for a Gas Tax: Drivers Could Save Money Melissa Lafsky appears on Fox Business, hardly a pro-tax forum, to explain the counterintuitive idea that gas tax could actually save drivers money.
"The average American driver," she says, "spends around $335 a year
repairing his or her car as a result of driving on unrepaired roads ...
Now, how do we get the money to repair roads? Through the gas tax! ...
If we were to raise the gas tax ...it would still cost you less per
year in those additional taxes than it's costing you to repair your
car." She further says that though supporting the gas tax is "akin to
political suicide," the reasons to push it are clear: "when you do the
numbers it's sort of obvious."
- The Liberal Case for Screaming Until Obama Does Something The Boston Globe's Derrick Jackson
is frustrated that Obama hasn't done more to move America towards a better energy situation. "Even as the BP oil disaster
continues in the Gulf of Mexico, sales of gas guzzlers zoomed up,
begging the question, 'what oil spill?'" He calls the foot-dragging on
this issue through the years "political cowardice" and points to the
gas tax's success in Europe as evidence that it could propel America
into a "clean energy future."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.