This week, Berkshire Hathaway CEO Warren Buffett and Microsoft chairman
Bill Gates called upon their fellow billionaires to pledge half their wealth to charitable causes
either in their lifetimes or after their deaths. It's the cornerstone
of an ambitious philanthropy initiative, the Giving Pledge, that
Buffett and Gates hope will circulate money to causes and organizations
that need it most. (Buffett has said that he eventually plans to give
away some 99 percent of his money.)
- This Can Only Lead to Good Things, concludes Carol Loomis
at Fortune. "Society cannot help but be a beneficiary here, by virtue
of at least some dollars and perhaps many," Loomis writes in a lengthy
piece that explains how Buffett and Gates came to develop their idea.
"Nor will it be just the very rich who will perhaps bend their minds to
what a pledge of this kind means. It could also be others with less to
give but suddenly more reason to think about the rightness of what they
- Morbid Thumbs Up From Bloomberg, Broad Michael Bloomberg,
the mayor of New York City, and Eli Broad, a philanthropist and former
CEO of SunAmerica, have endorsed
the Giving Pledge in principle, though their language was oddly
preoccupied with death. Broad and his wife released a statement saying
that "We agree with Andrew Carnegie's wisdom that 'the man who dies
rich, dies disgraced.'" Bloomberg, for his part, called the Pledge "a
fantastic idea" before taking his own turn into the thanatoid: "I am a
big believer in giving it all away and have always said that the best
financial planning ends with bouncing the check to the undertaker."
- How This Is Like AA The Economist
explains that billionaires who take the Pledge will write "a public
letter promising to donate 50% or more of their wealth. Mr Buffett
himself has written the first, which is published on a website ...
Although the letters will not be legally binding, they are intended to
create a moral obligation which will be reinforced by peer pressure
from others who take the pledge—a bit like members of Alcoholics
Anonymous who promise to stay off the booze."
- Maybe There's a
Better Way? "Bill Gates and Warren Buffett are trying to urge
billionaires around the world to give half their money to charity. That
would be great," writes Matt Yglesias
of Think Progress. "But maybe what we really need some super-rich
charitably inclined businessmen to do is finance some new ventures in
these quasi-utility markets like charge cards, cell phones, mortgage
origination, etc. based on a 'don't screw the customer over' business
model. The striking thing about the credit card universe, after all, is
that there's very little competition and no meaningful difference in
business practices between Visa and MasterCard. But I don't think it’s
written in stone anywhere that there can be only two."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
aeichler at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.