Foxconn Technology Group, which makes both Apple and Hewlett-Packard products in China, has announced
an impressive wage-raise for its factory workers in the wake of a
troubling rash of suicides. For those unfamiliar with the situation,
the story of worker welfare at a single company in China might seem
slightly arcane. The raise, though, is both an enormous one for the
individuals affected, and a move towards higher labor costs in China,
with potentially large effects for both China and the countries
receiving its exports.
- This Is a Heck of a Hike Ernie Smith
looks at the numbers at Shortformblog. The immediate increase in
salaries is 33%, he reports, while he also highlights "the monthly
amount [workers] could be making in three months": $300. That's "double
their current salaries," he points out.
- 'Tough' Decision,
May See More of Them "This is obviously a tough move for the company
to have to take given the notoriously low margins facing Chinese
manufacturers, plus the fact that the yuan has already been de facto revalued higher due to the collapsing euro," writes Business Insider's Joe Weisenthal.
"But obviously the previous situation is untenable, and we wouldn't be
surprised to see this move reverberate across the country, and then, by
extension across the world, to consumers that enjoy the fruits of cheap
- No, We Will See More of Them "China's wages will rise inexorably," predicts 24/7 Wall St.'s Douglas McIntyre.
"There are too many factors to push it up for the Chinese government to
push the trend down, even if it wanted to." He calls the country "the
victim of its own success," having "created a huge middle class ...
[that] expects a standard of living that relies on healthy wages, and
in a nation prone to inflation, raises." The pressure from Western
companies for better worker treatment is an issue, too, while China
increasingly, given Western countries' economic circumstances, "needs
its own consumers to buy its own manufactured goods"--that's only going
to happen if its consumers are making enough money to buy things. All
this, though, "leaves China in a bind," he says. "China is becoming a
high-cost provider of labor in a world where low labor costs are more
important than ever."
- Foxconn, Wal-Mart, the Long-Suffering Laborer Numerian
at The Agonist switches gears and draws a comparison between American
Wal-Mart workers and Chinese Foxconn workers, making a broader point
about the plight of the middle class in both countries:
In this complex, symbiotic chain, you have Chinese workers promised a
middle class lifestyle if only they put in their time at a place most
of them describe as a "prison." The promise is illusory, which is
becoming more and more apparent to the lowest of these workers. You
also have American middle class workers promised the ability to
maintain their lifestyle with everyday low prices at Wal-Mart, except
this promise too is illusory since corporations all across America keep
pressuring employees with salary freezes, benefit cuts, and ultimately
the risk of unemployment, which has now reached 17% of the workforce if
you count all disillusioned job seekers. Americans are now catching on
to how this game works as well.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.