The "information revolution" was supposed to "make cities irrelevant," explains Mario Polèse
in City Journal, but "that hasn't happened." Instead, "big cities have continued to grow." Why? And what challenges will that present to cities already struggling with numerous logistical challenges?
- 'Why Big Cities Matter More Than Ever' Big cities endure, according to Mario Polèse,
due to a
number of factors: "economies of scale in production ... economies of
scale in trade and transportation ... falling transportation and
communication costs ... the quest for the center," and the "buzz and
bright lights" factor. The "quest for the center" is about businesses
"naturally want[ing] to locate in the geographic center of their
markets." For all of these reasons, Polèse says that, despite the
challenges cities face ("municipal debt, onerous taxes, the cost of
living, and crumbling infrastructure"), "people will continue to seek
places where they can share ideas, make transactions, and pursue their
dreams." This ties in nicely with the "buzz and bright lights" idea:
and ambitious people benefit from being in a big city, just as firms
do--in part because the companies can hire talented and ambitious
workers. Some people move to cities not just because they need to make
a living (though being in a metropolis does offer all the advantages of
a diverse labor market) but also because they want to be where the
action is. Ambition, dreams, the need for recognition--all are powerful
forces in human behavior. Many a young man or woman will ask: Where are
my chances best of meeting the right people and doing exciting things?
The answer, for good reason, will often be the big city.
- Other Advantages James Joyner
at Outside the Beltway agrees on the necessity of people congregating
in one place: "I can frankly write from anywhere," he writes, "but
connections matter and, in the politics and foreign affairs realm,
they're going to be made in Washington and, to a lesser extent, New
York." In addition, he points out, he could lose his job today and have
"an excellent chance" of finding "comparable employment without moving.
There are only a handful of places on the planet where that would be
the case, all of them major cities."
- The Big Coming Problems: Transportation and Sustainability Ben Tuxworth
writes at Grist about the "crisis of mobility heading our way," as
growing cities already "struggling to provide effective mass transit"
try to keep up. He summarizes work done by Forum for the Future, which
"proposes a to-do list that includes curbing car use, prioritizing the
mobility needs of the poor, sharpening up integration between modes,
refueling vehicles with low-carbon alternatives to gasoline, and
changing behavior so that people travel fewer miles and by less
damaging modes." Businesses are already onto this problem, he explains:
to Chris Borroni-Bird, director of GM's advanced technology vehicle
concepts work, we're about to see a new chapter in the story of cars
and cities. "In the past 100 years, the automobile has shaped the city
... in the future, the opposite will be the case: cities will shape
mobility." ... The battle for sustainability will be won or lost in
cities. This point is not lost on the many businesses--among them GE,
sponsor of our Sustainable Cities Index--tooling up to provide the integrated city solutions of tomorrow.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.