Howard Kurtz is worried that the mainstream media has lost its sway. How else, he wonders, could scores of Americans really believe that the government may kill their grandmother? In his column yesterday, Kurtz applauds reporters for taking politicians like Sarah Palin who have promoted outlandish lies about health care to task. "For once, mainstream journalists did not retreat to the studied neutrality of quoting dueling antagonists," he said. And yet, paranoia over 'death panels' continues. Kurtz's conclusion: the mainstream media no longer has the influence over the national discourse that it once did.
"Perhaps journalists are no more trusted than
politicians these days, or many folks never saw the knockdown stories. But this
was a stunning illustration of the traditional media's impotence." Some
columnists say there might be other, kinder explanations.
Before the Media Reported the Facts, They Hyped the Lies,writes Ezra Klein at The Washington Post. “They cover the controversy. They cover
the lies and the untruths and the angry ads. Sometimes they fact-check these
documents and sometimes they don't.” Klein says simply giving airtime to outlandish
lies is enough to spread misinformation. “For the past few weeks, the casual
consumer of news has heard about death panels and illegal immigrants and
skyrocketing deficits and violent town halls. They may not believe all those
things. But they assume they're part of the national conversation for a reason,
and, quite naturally, they recoil from the center of it.” Klein's solution? "
Reporting the facts is important. But so too is not reporting -- or at least not focusing, day after day -- on the lies."
The Press is Content to Trust Liars,writes Tim Fernholz at The American Prospect. "Having identified Sarah Palin, Newt Gingrich, Chuck Grassley, John McCain and today, Michael Steele,
as spreading falsehoods about health care reform even after they have
been broadly discredited, will the journalists Kurtz mentions offer
them any sanction? Or will these public figures continue to be
extensively quoted in newspapers and on television?"
Kurtz is Right, says Glynnis MacNicol at Mediaite. "If the MSM were to disappear would anyone notice?" MacNicol says the health care debate could have been a great opportunity for the "beleaguered mainstream media" to prove it still mattered, but that the opportunity has been missed. "If we can't rely on news institutions to rationally explain the
complicated (and extremely important) issues of the day in a way that
will reach people, than why do we need them at all?"
Since When is the Media Supposed to Influence Public Opinion?asks
conservative opinion blogger Warner Todd Huston at Texas for Palin. "I
media's job was to report news so that readers could come to their own
conclusion? I thought a journalist was in the just-the-facts-m'am
business?" Huston said it's no surprise that Americans don't trust the
media, because journalists like Kurtz, "have been caught over and over
again in lies, obfuscation and omissions
not to mention your sycophancy for the Chief Death Panelist, The One,
The Atlantic Wire is your authoritative guide to the news and ideas that matter most right now. Our team tracks newsmakers and opinions across the entire media spectrum: newspapers, web sites, television, radio and magazines.
But we do more than just collect information. By synthesizing, analyzing and summarizing what’s out there, and adding new information when we can, we are a news engine that gives you a quick and valuable account of the issues of the day.