The Obama Justice Department announced
Monday that it will no longer prosecute growers or users of medical marijuana in states where such activities are legal. Unlike the fiercely contentious debates over health care, the economy, and the war in Afghanistan, commentators have met this this move--a rejection of hyper-aggressive enforcement under Bush--with nearly universal praise. From the conservative magazine National Review to prolific liberal blogger Glenn Greenwald, pundits find cause to celebrate the shift, though their reasons differ. Pro-legalization writers extoll it as an advance in the movement to legalize pot
, while states'-rights advocates praise it as an unusual
affirmation of their cause.
- Two Steps Forward At The National Review, Jonathan Adler says the decision is a "positive step toward a more rational drug control policy and greater respect for state-level policymaking." He wants to see pot regulated like alcohol. "Ideally, the federal government would treat marijuana like alcohol, retaining a federal role in controlling illegal interstate trafficking but leaving each state entirely free to set its own marijuana policy, whether it be prohibition, decriminalization, or somewhere in between."
Beyond the tangible benefits to patients and providers, there is the
issue of states' right. Fourteen states have legalized medical
marijuana, many by referendum. The Bush administration's refusal to
honor or even recognize those states' decisions -- by arresting people
for doing things which are perfectly legal under state law -- was one of many examples giving the lie to the conservative movement's alleged belief in federalism and limited federal power (see here,
for instance, how John Ashcroft and GOP Senators tried deceitfully and
undemocratically to exploit the aftermath of 9/11 to prevent Oregon
from implementing its assisted suicide law).
- Federal Sanity on Marijuana Nick Gillespie of Reason says "the Obama administration is making all the right noises on federal medical marijuana policy."
- Finally, Some Progress "A campaign promise that Obama kept," Joe Sudbay announces at AmericaBlog. Doug Mataconis, a blogger at Below the Beltway, agrees. He says that "the Obama Administration has finally brought an end to the Federal Government's insane war on sick people."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mgay at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.