5 Reasons Why the Golden Globes Trump the Oscars

John Hudson Jan 17, 2010
On Sunday evening American audiences will be treated to the 67th annual Golden Globe Awards. The ceremony, a celebration of the year's movies and TV shows presented by the Hollywood Foreign Press Association, often comes under fire for being little more than a frivolous, drunken gala for film and TV stars. But this year, a handful of entertainment reporters have taken it upon themselves to defend the award show, claiming it beats out the more-revered Oscars. Here are their arguments:
  • The Party Scene Is Unparalleled, writes Melena Ryzik at The New York Times: "It has the best party of the season and more stars in one room than a Scientology, Kabbalah and Forum meeting combined."
  • Globes Are on the Right Side of History, writes Darren Franich at Entertainment Weekly: "The [Golden Globes] arguably has a better track record than its more prestigious sibling. Look no further than three of the greatest miscarriages of Best Picture justice in Oscar history: CrashBrokeback Mountain, Shakespeare in Love beating Saving Private Ryan, and Ghandi beating E.T. The Extra-Terrestrial. All three losers have become essential classics, while the three winners’ reputations have all suffered."
  • Delightfully More Scandal-Prone Than the Oscars, writes Breeanna Hare at CNN: "What would the Globes be without a questionable moment or three? The 2006 red carpet featured a frisky Isaac Mizrahi, who happily went in for a grope while interviewing Scarlett Johansson; in 2009, there was a hilariously rude speech by Sacha Baron Cohen when he presented the best comedy award; and then there was Jack Nicholson's 2003 acceptance speech, when he acknowledged that he'd popped a Valium."
  • A Great Mix of High-Low Culture, adds Franich: "It’s completely nonsensical to think of James Cameron being in the same room as the cast of Cougar Town, or Christoph Waltz being just a couple tables away from the cast of Glee. But one of the zippy pleasures of the Globes is the high-low mixing of every level of the Hollywood stratosphere.
  • Way Less Boring, adds Hare: "The thing about watching the Academy Awards is that it drags...and drags...and drags to its final conclusion, when all you really wanted to see was who takes best picture. With the Globes, while you may take a bathroom break during the best original score category, by and large, the show keeps boring categories to a minimum."

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at jhudson at theatlantic dot com. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.

Sources

Topics:
Related Articles   More by John Hudson

James Franco to Do New Thing That Isn't Acting

Patton Oswalt Calls for a Pop Culture Ragnarok

Is Bristol Palin on 'DWTS' a Microcosm of 2012?

 

Europe Goes Back to Plan A: Greece Has Got to Stay

'War on Women' Won't Extend to the Nuclear Regulatory Commission

User Comments

Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register

  • The Atlantic Wire on Twitter
  • The Atlantic Wire RSS Feed
  • The Atlantic Wire iPhone App