This season will be Simon Cowell's last
as judge on Fox's smash-hit American Idol. The caustic Brit everyone
loves to hate is stepping down to bring his show X Factor to American
audiences next year. Few predict Idol--one of the rare programs attracting Americans across income, age, and race--will keep its massive audience of 26 million after Cowell leaves. So what does America owe the wedge-haired naysayer? Here's what entertainment critics think:
- He Made Us All Critics, writes Stephen Marche at Esquire: "The sense of entitlement to judge everyone and everything, all day and
every day, feeds and fuels our pop-culture appetite, and it finds its
broadest, most democratic expression in the Idol
format," he says. Cowell, "the hard man," is the only judge whose
opinion really matters. "Often he's just saying what everyone else is
too polite to say."
- He Gave America Its Favorite Show, write Scott Collins and Denise Martin at the L.A. Times: "Even discounting Cowell's self-infatuated shtick, it's likely that his exit from Idol will mark the end of an era for America's No. 1 series and broadcast TV... if viewers decide a non-Simonized Idol isn't
worth watching. Cowell is the 'mean judge' who levels direct, often
withering appraisals at wide-eyed young contestants. His background as
a music executive gives him a credibility that is matched by his
ability to encapsulate what viewers were often feeling."
- He Made Being a Prick Cool, writes Jonathan Berr at Daily Finance: "He never makes any bones about viewing Idol
as a self- promotional vehicle, and his brutal honesty in a world of
show business phoniness is downright refreshing. And it won't be much
of a surprise if even viewers who loathe the prickly Brit find
themselves changing the channel after this season ends."
- Brought a Diverse Country Together, writes Richard Rushfield at The Daily Beast: "Idol's Big Tent has accommodated everyone from fundamentalist
Christians to pop divas, but in an increasingly divided nation [and with Cowell's exit], will
that spirit of friendly competition between the tribes stand?"
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
jhudson at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.