Veteran reporter Gerald Posner has been suspended from his
staff-writing position at The Daily Beast following claims of
plagiarism. The allegations came from Slate columnist Jack Shafer
who was tipped off by one of his readers. Shafer looked into Posner's
work and discovered a variety of pilfered material from The Miami Herald, Texas Lawyer and a "health care journalism
blog." Following the suspension, Posner issued this apology on his blog:
Today I found out that I am suspended from my Chief Investigative
Reporter position at The Daily Beast. I now realize that a method of
compiling information that I have used successfully since 1984 on book
research obviously does not work in a fail safe manner at the warp
speed of the net. Some of the incidents raised by Jack Shafer are not plagiarism, but are
instances in which I received the same exact prepared quotation or
statement from a police officer or press agent as other reporters. But
others are mistakes I deeply regret. Rest assured, no one has been tougher on me than I have over this
Here's how bloggers are responding:
- I Don't Buy It, writes Joseph Cannon: "Is this an admission that he cribbed words in his books? Is this an
admission that Posner is not really a writer but a compiler of
information? How is it that I (and every other blogger) can deal with
the net's warp speed but Gerry can't?"
- Surprise, Surprise, clucks Margaret Soltan:
" Plagiarized articles are like roaches. Find one, and ten others will
come scurrying out of the plagiarist's past." This makes the case for
"tougher editing," adds Gabriel Sherman.
- Posner's Apology Has a Point, writes Kyle Munzenrieder at The Miami New Times: "Posner is often credited for his research skills in book reviews. He even wrote about the Novaks in Babylon.
It's interesting he partially blames the net, though there's no denying
there's a big difference between taking months to research a book and
the never-ending deadline of the World Wide Web."
- Don't Beat Yourself Up About It, writes Paul Brandus, a commenter on Posner's blog: "You have a good track record, Mr. Posner, and I think you're entitled
to make a mistake every quarter century or so. I work in the White
House as a reporter and the torrent of info is indeed difficult to deal
with sometimes. Learn from your mistakes and move on - but don't beat
yourself up. I have tremendous respect for your work and look forward
to your next book. Best regards."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
jhudson at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.