Point Omega, the new novel from acclaimed postmodernist Don DeLillo, has neatly divided American critics. One group lauds the book's stark,
and the strength of its intellectual architecture
other is turned off by bloodless characters
and the glacial creep of
the story, which can't be said to have a plot so much as a duration.
Point Omega's nominal subjects are the Iraq War and its philosophical
consequences. But really, as many critics note, it's a book about things winding down,
losing momentum, and coming to a full and complete stop.
- A Meditative Exercise Disguised as a Novel Writing in the Los Angeles Times, Matthew Sharpe
is exhilarated by DeLillo's nothing-much-happens approach to plotting.
"The book's methodology is also one of its themes: The life-defining
events are the ones usually considered interstitial. The action is in
the dead spots... it has been enlivening, challenging, harrowing and
beautiful to imagine Point Omega."
- Human Beings Not Included At The New York Times, Michiko Kakutani
is less enthralled, criticizing the novel's "suffocating and airless"
quality before noting that "the three characters here do not live in a
recognizable America or
recognizable reality -- rather, they feel like roles written for a
stylized and highly contrived theater piece... They are roles
desperately in need of actors to flesh them
out and give them life."
- It Takes Fewer Muscles to Smile Esquire's Benjamin Alsup
remembers when DeLillo would cut his sobering parables with a few
jokes. "If you go back to DeLillo's earlier work... you'll be struck by
the laughs that accompany the impending doom.
This is gallows humor for sure, but humor nonetheless. The mature
DeLillo, by contrast, is maybe a little ripe. Amidst all the high
seriousness, I miss the high ironies."
- Time to Try Other Forms? In New York Magazine, Sam Anderson, a self-described "raging DeLillo fan," thinks he understands what the author is trying to do. "I get the sense that he wants his oeuvre to culminate in a pure act of
attention, and I'm not convinced that the novel is the best medium in
which to do that... I'd be more excited to see
him branch out to another genre--an experimental autobiography, or
essayistic micro-observations of his favorite art and literature--than
write another short novel about detached and largely interchangeable
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
aeichler at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.