Earlier this week, the Wire covered the fight
erupting between Sharon Waxman
of The Wrap and Newser founder Michael Wolff
To recap: Waxman says Newser practices underhanded aggregation, tossing up ads when you try to follow links to the original sources, and failing to display those links prominently. Wolff says the links are plenty visible, and mounts a full-throated defense of aggregation as a valuable condensing service. Now, The
Wrap's attorneys have fired off a cease and desist letter. Waxman and Wolff exchanged fire once again. (And for the especially interested, they will be squaring off at least one more time in a debate this Sunday on
- Cease and Desist The lawyers demand Newser stop using The Wrap content, as "Newser is not following industry best practices." Waxman sums it up sans legalese:
we really want is for Newser to stop pissing on our leg and tell us
it's raining. Very simply: put in credit and links where they are
missing. Add a Wrap homepage link to the source grid page. Make it
simple and logical to get to actual Wrap content from that page.
- Desist This Wolff
returns that "a quick search shows [Waxman's] site doing even more
blatantly and systematically what she accuses us of doing--taking a
free-ride on other people's content." He also defends Newser's
practices. "Every Newser story contains two automated links to the
source," he states. Another emphatic clarification: "Our business is
not news gathering, it is news curation and summarization." He lists a
number of other publications doing the same thing.
We believe that summarizing adds value. And we believe it is ethical:
We don’t take words; we don't take expression; we don’t take photos or
video; what we do is reduce to the facts and then add our own
headlines, and licensed photos and videos to improve the ability to
immediately understand a story.
Wolff concludes with a response to the cease and desist letter, which he thinks is on
shaky ground because The Warp's content isn't "time-sensitive" and Newser
isn't a direct competitor. The letter, he argues, is really about
"self-promotion," by which measure "it has succeeded: Waxman and I will
be debating all this (if you can stand it) on Howard Kurtz's CNN show at 11am on Sunday morning." Stay tuned.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.