THESIS: You may love Law & Order, but Law & Order doesn't love you. In fact, Law & Order probably hates you
WHY LAW & ORDER PROBABLY HATES YOU: You probably belong to one of the categories of people the series obsessively demonizes--of which there are many
THINGS THAT ARE NOT LAW & ORDER'S 'MOST REMARKABLE FEATURE': "the brilliant formula that offers both the comfort of predictability and the promise of constant surprise ... the ability of the show to survive major cast changes without missing a beat, ... the considerable accomplishment of making the arcane vocabulary of the law ( 'fruit of the poisoned tree,' 'asked and answered,' 'prejudicial,' 'allocute,' 'goes to relevance') as familiar to TV viewers as the jargon of sports"
LAW & ORDER'S 'MOST REMARKABLE FEATURE': "the extraordinarily long list of professions, classes and category of persons it doesn't like"
PEOPLE HATED BY LAW & ORDER: "Rich people," "children of rich people," doctors, priests, rabbis, evangelical Christians, "high-roller businessmen, developers, drug manufacturers ... actors, rock stars, athletes, artists, dancers, high-profile academics, writers,"any lawyer who does not work "for the people," FBI agents, judges, politicians
THE COMMON ELEMENT (OR WHY LAW & ORDER AND SESAME STREET, SADLY, ARE FUNDAMENTALLY OPPOSED): "What links those who inhabit these various categories is that they are not ordinary folks. 'Law & Order' hates people who stand out."
HEROES OF LAW & ORDER: "those who soldier on day after day"
MORAL OF LAW & ORDER: "the liberal state is committed to a regime of justice that is not a respecter of persons, but persons--especially persons who have managed to distinguish themselves in some way--are forever working to undermine it"
HOW TO BE SOMEONE LAW & ORDER LIKES:
The only way to be O.K. in Dick Wolf's world is to have a job that is steady but doesn't pay very much, to drive a five year old car you're still paying off, to live in a small house with a large mortgage, to have an education that helps you get by but doesn’t give you any fancy ideas, to attend a house of worship that is the center of your social life, and to have almost no leisure time. Unless you fit that profile, "Law & Order" probably doesn't like you.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.
Heather Horn



User Comments
Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register