This moment has been coming for quite some time. It was pretty much
inevitable the second that Danny Boyle attached himself to a true story
project about an outdoorsman who amputated his own arm to avoid starving
to death. Well, here it is, 127 Hours
with James Franco. It's as violent as the premise implied, with crowds
at film festivals, private screenings and premieres all reacting in
disgust to the cringe-worthy sequences when the actor attempts to hack,
gnaw and otherwise sever his limb. Franco is also getting quite a few
rave responses. But queasy film goers, just take note what's been
said about those scenes in question:
Slate - "Honestly, I watched that part through intermittently covered eyes."
Fox Searchlight Co-President - "I would prefer that people not pass out — it’s not a plus...We don’t see a particular publicity value in it."
Movie Line:Final Tally of People Affected: "Faintings: 13-16, Light-headedness: 2,
Seizures: 3, Panic attacks: 1, Vomiting: Unknown, Exorcist mentions: 3"
The New York Times
- "The cracking of a bone, the severing of a nerve, the desperate
consumption of a water bag filled with urine...what these moments
communicate is more than worth a jolt of discomfort or a spasm of
Entertainment Weekly - "Hey, what better compliment than proof that they’ve made you literally feel for a character?"
The Los Angeles Times-
"The amputation scene that caused all the panic is hardly that graphic,
and the incidents have occurred at a rate of of a fraction of 1%."
Danny Boyle- "It’s not a hype thing, and they’re OK. But I think the vast majority
of the audience appreciates the experience of going on such an intense
The Atlantic Wire is your authoritative guide to the news and ideas that matter most right now. Our team tracks newsmakers and opinions across the entire media spectrum: newspapers, web sites, television, radio and magazines.
But we do more than just collect information. By synthesizing, analyzing and summarizing what’s out there, and adding new information when we can, we are a news engine that gives you a quick and valuable account of the issues of the day.