Newsweek's Jessica Bennett
had a piece this week about how women on reality TV
aren't exactly giving women a good name. She takes a look at Jennifer
Pozner's new book Reality Bites Back: The Troubling Truth About Guilty
Pleasure TV, and points out that
if your main source of
knowledge about women came from reality TV, this is how you'd see the
world: a place where your mom is a conniving, deceitful gold digger,
your sisters and girlfriends vicious and catty. You would learn that
"sisterhood" is a thing of the past, as Pozner puts it--and that girl
friendships are not powerful but spiteful. And you’d understand that
women were put on this earth to compete for male attention--when, of
course, they're not busy pulling each other's hair out or lounging half
naked in a hot tub.
But which shows are the "worst offenders"? Kay Steiger
asks this very question to Jennifer Pozner in an interview at The American
Prospect. Bennett talks about America's Next Top Model and Flavor of
Love, as well as Who Wants to Be a Millionaire? Pozner says "it's a
toss-up." In the Bachelorette, there's
"mock earnestness about true love," the message being that "every girl
wants to be a princess and every boy is Prince Charming, you know, as
long as he's wealthy and has a firm ass," and "the only way to be
successful, the only way to be happy, the only way to be financially or
personally fulfilled or secure is by glomming on to any guy that will
have you." Meanwhile Joe Millionaire and Flavor of Love are "done with
a sort of a wink and a nod to viewers." In other words, "we're supposed
to, on the surface, understand that the women are gold diggers, or that
the women are stupid and bimbos, and we're supposed to laugh at them."
The sexism is different. Asks Pozner: "is it better or worse when shows package themselves as sincere
or when the sexism is totally overt?"
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.