- Linda Hirshman on Why Republicans Should Give Up on DOMA At Salon today, Linda Hirshman argues that it "would be a mistake" for Republicans to defend the Defense of Marriage Act in court if it does not approve of the administration's recent decision not to enforce what it sees as an unconstitutional law. Hirshman points out that those who attempted to defend Proposition 8 in California court proved that there is no sound, legitimate argument for depriving same sex couples of the same benefits opposite sex couples receive. The arguments against gay marriage are based solely in religion. "The prohibition is the last vestige of the religious belief that homosexuality is sinful, a rare application of the language of the Old Testament to otherwise victimless behavior in a secular society. (One of the hardest things about talking to God is finding an expert to give a proper deposition)," she writes, pointing out that those who have testified in the past against gay marriage "didn't just look dumb--they looked mean." Hirshman can see why it would be tempting for Republicans to fight: their supporters are overwhelmingly against gay marriage. But considering the fact, according to the latest poll, that gay marriage is not actually something these supporters care much about (as compared to, say, the deficit) Hirshman suggests House Republicans do themselves a favor and leave the issue alone.
- Conrad Black on Why Libya Is Different Conrad Black lays out lays out the stages of disturbance that can occur in an uprising: "First, strikes and widespread demonstrations; second, widespread violence and civil disorder; third, direct attacks on the leadership; fourth, the overthrow by physical armed takeover of the instruments of government and the arrest, rout, or execution of the leaders." He says the "litmus tests are: Will the regime order the use of live ammunition on crowds, and will the orders be carried out? If the answers to those questions are positive, only a very well-organized and fervent opposition will succeed." The way things are going so far, it doesn't look like Bahrain has much of a chance of forcefully uprooting it's leadership. Libya, however, "has gone beyond stage two," and the Libyan people's resistance toward Qaddafi's violence may encourage the people of Iran, whose opposition contains powerful Iranians. Though "it is unlikely that whatever government emerges in Egypt will be a significant change from what Egypt has had," in Libya, as in all places "where governments are so brutal and incompetent that the people are disgusted," there is a chance for real change. Ultimately, he argues, once all of the violence subsides, only those countries that focus on economic development will succeed in achieving real democracy.
- Dirk Vandewalle on the Many Faces of Qaddafi Vandewalle, a government associate professor at Dartmouth as well as the author of Modern
today in the New York Times about the many twists and turns in the
narrative of Qaddafi's 42 year rule. There was Qaddafi the
revolutionary, the young man who came to power through a coup, Qaddafi
the Arab nationalist, Qaddafi as "mastermind of international
terrorism," Qaddafi the "would-be philosopher" and Qaddafi the clownish
demagogue. In 2003 Qaddafi was able to rehabilitate his image temporarily by convincing the
world that his violent ways were behind him. Qaddafi has always
envisioned himself as "a global figure of major proportion, a visionary
thinker whose ideas about democracy were worthy of serious intellectual
contemplation," Vandewalle writes. But with his brutal crackdown on the
opposition in Libya the "image of Colonel Qaddafi as the vicious monster
who will go to any lengths to survive has reappeared." It might never
have truly disappeared in the first place, Vandewalle implies.
Johnson on China's Growing Drug Problem In the latest round of debates
on China's challenge to the United States' global supremacy, the British
historian and author presents
a new angle on what may hold the world's largest country back: gambling
and drugs. Writing in Forbes, Johnnson recalls the Opium Wars of the
19th century but then cites a recent survey that has shown 40 percent of the heroin
from Afghanistan and Pakistan now go to China. While he acknowledges
that countries undergoing economic development typically see increases
in drug use, China might end up caught in a vicious cycle of addiction
followed by government oppression mirroring the government's response in
the 19th century. Organized crime and corruption are sure to be
factors. "The Chinese are learning that prosperity comes at a price,"
- Andrew Edgecliffe-Johnson on Apple's Gamble Writing
in the Financial Times, Edgecliffe-Johnson believes Apple is making a
risky bet in the tablet market by demanding a 30 percent fee for every
subscription purchased for the iPad. Big media conglomerates may be able to
live with this fee, Edgecliffe-Johnson notes, but start-ups "could be
crushed by such a toll." Edgecliffe-Johnson suggests that Apple might be
leaving itself vulnerable to competitors who are willing to offer lower
rates, noting that Google's subscription service for Android takes only
a 10 percent cut. Compared to iTunes, which quickly established itself
as the dominant force in digital music, "the tablet market and
subscription apps are at an earlier stage" and could give media owners
and technology firms an opportunity to challenge Apple's dominance.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the authors at
cdickson at theatlantic dot com or erosenberg at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.