It's like 'a cigarette break in the eye of a hurricane' says Neil McCormick at the Telegraph. "Radiohead's 8th album may, in fact, be their most immediately accessible ... it is easy on the ear, with a mellifluous melodiousness and gentle sonic palette that doesn't demand huge leaps of faith. Percussive, groovy, spacious, ethereal and melodic, this is late night Radiohead, a stoned, somnambulistic wander through the urban wastelands." Verbiage supply unexhausted, he adds: "Radiohead somehow finds a space between the sinister and the beautiful, the tense and the meditative."
It's actually 'like being lost in a dense forest'... and being an embryo, writes James Montgomery at MTV. "Limbs is assuredly the most minor thing Radiohead have ever done, a dour, insular, downright atmospheric thing that, from the skittering, jazzy fractals of opening track 'Bloom' to the slowly decaying guitars and pitter-pat drums of closer 'Separator,' works very hard at creating a mood ... one that is part amniotic, part pastoral, yet all washed over in a gauzy, dreamlike haze." Montgomery nevertheless concludes that the "minor album" is still a "major accomplishment," and never clarifies what, precisely, he means by "amniotic."
'The light and shade' that had begun to appear in their music has been 'snuffed out' adds Tim Jonze at the Guardian, saying that Radiohead, thought of as "musical mavericks operating in the mainstream," has "failed to come up with anything that might surprise us ... you can still marvel that one of the world's biggest bands are releasing music totally lacking in commercial concerns ... But whereas their business model is unusual, there's a nagging feeling that The King of Limbs is more like business as usual."
It’s more 'like the onomatopoeia of a Heaney poem' says Ronan at Swear I'm Not Paul. "In Rainbows grabbed me more on first listen, but I feel that this album might have a lot more to discover underneath," he writes but the opening is terrible. "If this song is your first introduction to Radiohead ... then you might be wondering what all the fuss is about."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
erosenberg at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.
Eli Rosenberg



User Comments
Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register