Is the protracted
White House debate on Afghanistan being dragged out
? With Senator McCain warning against taking too much time to formulate strategy, and presidential adviser David Axelrod countering that the president is "taking a lot of time" in order to give the matter "real thought," the question is this: How much time is too much? Former Secretary of State Madeleine Albright joins some heavyweight foreign policy commentators in the debate over Obama's drawn out deliberation.
- Don't Rush It, But Nine Months Should Be Enough to Decide "Personally," begins the Washington Post's David Ignatius, "I think [Obama is] wise to take his time on
an issue in which it's so hard to know the right answer." But that's as complimentary as he gets. "Obama wants to avoid any semblance of a 'rush to war,'" he notes. "Nine months on, that doesn't seem like a danger." Calling the current president different from his predecessor, "occasionally to a fault," Ignatius concludes that "Obama needs to decide--soon--how the United States can best help
Kabul in a way that's politically sustainable in Washington"
- But This Is How Decision-Making Is Done, affirms former secretary of state Madeleine Albright, commenting on MSNBC on Wednesday. "I
actually think that everything is going the way it should in terms
of the decision-making process," she responds to those who quibble. "I
[want] a confident president rather
than a certain president." She also rejects the notion that consensus is a
waste of time: "what has to happen in these meetings, and they don't
work if this is not really happening," she says, drawing on her
cabinet experience, is "a different statement of views ... people
debating with each other over whether their point of view is right or
wrong ... I teach about decision making," she adds, "and this is actually the best way to do it."
- Shows Obama's 'Fetish' for Consensus Commentary magazine's Jennifer Rubin
takes up where Ignatius leaves off, calling Obama's decision-making
process "academic" and "indecisive." Really, she asks "is the
a graduate course on international relations?"
- Take Your Time--And Use It to Pressure Karzai Andrew Exum's (a.k.a. Abu Muqawama) original take on the matter suggests that Obama should deliberately prolong the decision. He urges making an even bigger show of consensus and public debate. "Why? Well," explains the Center for a New American Security blogger, "if the White House uses this time wisely, it should be putting
pressure on Hamid Karzai at the same time in which signals are being
sent that the U.S. mission in Afghanistan is at a fork in the road. Our
committment, we should be telling Karzai, is at least partially
dependent on what his government does and fails to do."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.