The Atlantic's own superblogger Andrew Sullivan crowns fellow pundits with an array of awards
complimentary, some critical. Each one is cleverly named after some
figure who exemplifies the award, such as the Yglesias Award, named for
the intellectually self-critical Matt Yglesias
. But blogger Matt Zeitlin
wonders if one prize, the Von Hoffman award, handed out for egregiously wrong predictions (and given as recently as Dec. 17
), hasn't gone out of date:
How can Andrew Sullivan still have the Von Hoffman award when Von Hoffman has been proven basically right?
York Observer columnist Nicholas von Hoffman notoriously predicted
American failure in Afghanistan in 2001, just as troops were marching into Kabul. Has the swing in fortunes
in Afghanistan proven Nicholas von Hoffman right, warping the award's original meaning?
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
bcarlson at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.