- Clarification, Not Change The Atlantic's Marc Ambinder explains. "The goal was not -- so much -- to send a message to world or to Afghanistan or Pakistan today; it was to bring some clarity to a confused press discourse on the question of a U.S. commitment to Afghanistan and the nature of the July, 2011 'withdrawal commencement' date."
- Proves Folly Of Timetables Commentary's Jennifer Rubin scoffs. "They had to, of course. The contradiction between the need for a full commitment to a critical war and an artificial date for withdrawal is too vast and unsustainable, both logically and politically," she writes. "If [Senator John] McCain is right and success in a counterinsurgency depends on unnerving the enemy, reference to a withdrawal date was a significant misstep. On the other hand, it’s rather plain that no one in the administration is willing to defend a date-certain deadline."
- Obama Wants It Both Ways But he can't have it, says L.A. Times's Andrew Malcolm. "[Obama's speech] was, in effect, a deft political speech designed by the White House to have it both ways -- tough talk about protecting America for the national security fanciers alongside a vow that it wouldn't last long for the anti-war folks and as a warning to slow-moving Afghans to get going," Malcolm writes. "But in a classic case of White House walkback, to once again have it both ways down the road, in the succeeding six days Obama Cabinet members have been fudging the July 2011 pullout start."
- White House Reassures Hawks National Review's Pete Hegseth, a former Army Captain, polishes his hawk credential as he praises Obama's clarification. "Yes, the president delayed his decision, but he’s now rushing troops to the front. Yes, the president set a tentative timeline, but he is allowing Secretary Gates and General McChrystal to reassure our allies and the Afghan people that it’s tentative. And yes, the president continues to bad-mouth the legacy of Iraq (which infuriates Iraq veterans), but his decision is evidence that he’s actually learned the right lessons from that war’s surge."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at mfisher at theatlantic dot com. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.


User Comments
Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register