President Obama, who came into office hoping for diplomatic
engagement with the Iranian regime, has taken a much tougher stance of
late. The U.S. is deploying a system of missile shields
to nations bordering Iran, and Defense Secretary Robert Gates is calling
for tough economic sanctions. On Monday, Iran has reiterated its goal of
enriching uranium for a medical reactor. Many watchers suspect Iran
actually seeks to build a nuclear bomb, leading the U.S., along with
France and Russia, to demand
stronger sanctions. Can it work?
- Iran Calls Our Bluff The Daily Beast's Michael Adler isn't optimistic.
"Iran has reacted to the leverage applied against it by increasing its
atomic work." "Washington's current strategy of holding out for
moving toward sanctions may not be enough to break this cycle. [...]
The United States may be trapped into a stillborn
policy of doing too little, too late if it seriously seeks to rein in
Iran's nuclear ambitions."
- Think Big on Sanctions Congressional Quarterly's Morton Kondracke says
the White House has to get tougher with "a 'coalition of the willing'
with Europe to
impose tough economic Sanctions. One talked-of action is
an international economic boycott of entities connected with the Iran
Revolutionary Guard Corps, the powerful political-military-clerical
conglomerate that now controls the country, including much of its
energy and nuclear program. Another is isolation of Iran’s central bank
from international commerce, which could collapse the value of Iran’s
- Why Iran Won't Nuke Israel Middle East blogger Gregg Carlstrom challenges
fears that Iran's nuclear program is an existential threat to Israel,
noting that Iran has spent decades championing the Palestinian cause.
"If Iran did that, it would irradiate a large chunk of historic
Palestine, rendering it uninhabitable for decades. Not a very effective
way to help the Palestinians," he writes. "There's no evidence that
Iran's nuclear weapons program is motivated by
anything other than self-interest -- national pride, perhaps, or a (not
unreasonable) sense of insecurity."
Iran's Slim Technical Capabilities The Institute for Science and International Security assesses.
"Iran may seek to project defiance, strength, and technical prowess,
despite deficits in all but the first." Iran's plan requires enriching
uranium to 20%, which they can do; fabricating fuel rods, which is
possible but involves significant challenges; and building ten
enrichment plants, which ISIS says is beyond Iran's capability "anytime
- Sanctions Will Never Work The Weekly Standard's John Noonan suggests Obama leverage Iran's political turmoil. "He can start by treating revolutionaries like Reagan treated the Polish
Solidarity movement, recognizing an Iranian government in exile, and
initiating an underground logistical line of techno gadgets like
laptops and cell phones with encrypted uplinks, radio-broadcasting
equipment, GPS transmitters, even iPods to assist in messaging --
anything that will ensure that a democratic revolution, not atomic
devices, is the only thing that reaches critical mass."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.