Some were skeptical
of Vice President Joe Biden's trip to Israel before his plane even left
the ground--they doubted the avuncular VP's ability to carry out the mission with reassurance and delicacy. But the biggest embarrassment
of the trip so far hasn't come from Biden's side. The Israeli
government provocatively announced new settlements in East Jerusalem while Biden was in the city to jump-start peace talks. American commentators interpret this as a humiliating slap, though some argue it's a misstep for the Israeli government. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu claims not to have known the
announcement was coming because it was decided by a Jerusalem planning
committee. Is that true? What could those in charge possibly have been
- Who Knows--It's a Terrible Idea Uri Dromi
for The International Herald-Tribune thinks there's something worse
than the bad diplomacy: "By expanding settlements instead of separating
from the Palestinians while we still can, we Israelis are dooming
ourselves to lose the Jewish and democratic state that has been won
with so much sacrifice." If settlements make the eventual separation of
states impossible, Palestinians will have to be granted Israeli
citizenship and voting rights, where their higher birth rate will
quickly move them to majority status. Juan Cole
agrees at his blog: "The Palestinians cannot be left stateless ...
forever. If they can't have Palestinian citizenship, then they'll have
to have Israeli citizenship."
- Netanyahu Knew About It Israeli Prime Minister Netanyahu claimed he was
unaware of the move, which was the decision of a "Jerusalem district
planning committee." The Guardian Simon Tisdall
says this is possible, "but the announcement was promulgated by his
interior ministry ... If Netanyahu did not know, then why not?" At the
very least, it's "hard to credit" interior minister Eli Yishai's
"protestations of innocence." Foreign Policy's Blake Hounshell agrees that claim, at least, "doesn't pass the laugh test."
- Old Trick for Political Gain Jackson Diehl of the Washington Post says this is a tried-and-true tactic for the Israeli right, and that Biden should have seen it coming: "The ambushing of high-level American visitors to Jerusalem via the announcement of new settlements is a tried-and-true tactic of Israeli hardliners seeking to derail peace negotiations. It dates back at least to the early 1990s." Reihan Salam at The Daily Beast argues that "The move will enhance the nationalist 'street cred' of its architects."
- Contempt The Atlantic's Andrew Sullivan
takes the news as evidence that he's "not imagining these things";
Israel really does have a "'Go Cheney Yourself' policy on the peace
process," and a "contemptuous attitude toward the US."
- Uncontroversial, Actually "Ramat Shlomo is a Haredi (ultra-Orthodox) Jewish neighborhood in Jerusalem that already has more than 20,000 residents," protests Israeli blogger Carl in Jerusalem. "[It] was in no-man's land before 1967" and "was never supposed to be an issue with the 'Palestinians.'"
- Israeli Independence Theater, Political Incompetence, Coincidence Haaretz's Bradley Burston
acknowledges the political profit for the "hard right," and says the
move "mines an emotional vein along a relatively small but potent
segment of the Israeli electorate, which holds that to insult Israel's
indispensible ally is to assert the Jewish state's independence." It's
about "expung[ing] any trace of ... groveling to the colonial master."
That said, Burston is believes the move is stupid
Chalk it up, if you like, to the powerful
pro-settler presence in certain strata of Israel's bureaucracy. Or
credit the mercurial, not to say, erratic, policy style of Defense
Minister and Labor Party Chairman Ehud Barak. Or accept the official
explanation that the timing of the decision was coincidence, entirely
unconnected with the vice-presidential visit.
In the anarchic swirl of current Israeli governance, the correct answer may well be: all three.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.