Could China be in for a sharp shock? Recent press on the nascent giant
hasn't been good: attacks on school children have raised concerns
about social and demographic tension, while some question
the sustainability of China's export-led growth. Now, experts within
China are warning of a housing bubble potentially far worse than the
one the U.S. experienced prior to the 2008 financial crisis. This news
comes along with worrisome larger economic numbers for the month of
May. Could China be teetering on the same precipice other countries faced two years ago?
- China Housing Bubble Bigger than U.S. or UK Version In an interview with the Financial Times, Li Daokui, on the Chinese central bank's monetary policy committee, calls
the Chinese "housing market problem ... much more fundamental, much
bigger" than the pre-financial crisis issues in other countries. "China
is running the risk or is on the verge of overheating," he says, and
the problem goes beyond the bubble itself. He argues for, as FT's Geoff
Dyer summarizes, "a gradual appreciation in the currency."
- Translation: Social Problems a Factor, Too, offers Laura Mortkowitz
at The Big Money. "One reason why the housing troubles in China have
the potential to be worse than what the United States faced before the
financial crisis is that China faces social discontent." Or, as
Business Insider's Joe Weisenthal puts it, "high prices cause their own societal problems."
- This May Lead to Action "Many observers had assumed that China would not raise rates," explains finance blogger Yves Smith
at Naked Capitalism. "But the interview makes clear that rising social
pressures are leading the government to try to take the air out of the
housing bubble. The government appears to be starting with measures
like tax measures that affect real estate only."
- Concerns About Growth Joe Weisenthal,
commenting on the FT interview with Li Daokui, also notes that Chinese
prime minister Wen Jiabao is meanwhile sending his own message: "Dear
countries that import our products, don't start slowing down." But
other commentators and analysts, such as Daily Finance's Lauren Cooper, point out that there are signs
of a slowdown, "at least according to the Purchasing Managers' Index
numbers released today by the China Federation of Logistics and
Purchasing. The figures indicate that the increase in factory output,
the rate of hiring and new orders declined in May ... The numbers may
indicate that there is less demand for products both at home and
abroad." At 24/7 Wall St., Douglas McIntyre observes that the crisis in Europe "may hasten the slowdown and even drive China industrial expansion to a halt."
- Which Could in Turn Lead to Inaction, suggests Weisenthal's Business Insider colleague Vincent Fernando.
"Lack of clarity, plus recent Chinese concerns in regards to global
growth threats, makes significant further tightening efforts less
likely in the near-term."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.