The United Nations has warned
that the biggest challenge in the ongoing relief efforts for the
millions displaced by flooding in Pakistan is the lack of money and
supplies. Over a million Pakistanis lack even a tent to sleep in, and as
many as 13.8 million have no access to clean drinking water, threatening
outbreaks of serious diseases such as cholera, particularly among
children. In the wake of the earthquake in Haiti, agencies and
individuals around the world were far more generous, donating $1 billion
USD within days. Why has the world been so much more sparing with
Pakistan?
- 'Paltry and Pathetic Response' Former U.S. Ambassador to Morocco Marc Ginsberg writes,
"UN Secretary General Ban Ki Moon, with the strong backing of the Obama
Administration, plans to convene an emergency UN meeting to kick start
international donations on August 19...with the U.S. already having
directed $76 million in urgent emergency flood relief...evidenced by
U.S. military helicopters running relief supplies ferried in from U.S.
bases throughout the region. Unfortunately, of the $460 million deemed
immediately needed by the UN for disaster relief barely 50% has actually
been delivered, the lion's share from the U.S. and other western
nations. Indeed, Deputy British Prime Minister Nick Clegg deemed the
international response to be 'absolutely pitiful' with fully 25% of the
assistance coming from the UK so far."
- No Sudden, 'Telegenic' Loss of Life The New York Times' Neil MacFarquhar writes,
"The international outpouring after recent disasters like Haiti or the
Asian tsunami in 2004 was driven partly by the huge, sudden loss of life
and the striking images of rescue efforts, he said. A slow-moving flood
with a death toll of about 1,500 people fails to provoke a similar
reaction." UN humanitarian coordinator John Holmes adds, "An
earthquake is a much more dramatic, emotional, telegenic event because
it happens so quickly."
- Americans 'Wary' of Pakistani Government The Los Angeles Times notes,
"Americans may be wary of sending more cash to a Pakistani government
with limited capacity, one accused of being corrupt at home and a
suspect ally in neighboring Afghanistan. Yet the U.S. government and
others must step up the pace and scale of help to Pakistan. Individual
donors too must open their wallets, as they did after Haiti's earthquake
and the South Asian tsunami, if not directly to the Pakistani
government, then to trusted private groups working there."
- Donor Fatigue from Haiti The New York Times staff editorial speculates,
"Or, perhaps, the floods were overshadowed by the out-of-control fires
in Russia or were neglected because many donors were already fatigued
from the challenge of rebuilding Haiti."
- Poor Marketing Former United Nations Deputy Secretary General Mark Malloch Brown tells the BBC,
"The leadership of Pakistan on the civilian side has gotten off to a
rather muddled and slow start. It’s very hard for donor governments —
let alone donor public opinion — to be entirely convinced at the
seriousness of a crisis when the country’s president is filmed at his
own private chateau in France
or continuing with government visits to the U.K. Crises, it’s a
terrible thing to say but, you know, they require disciplined marketing.
There needs to be a clear message that lives are at stake and the whole
of the domestic effort of the country is devoted to trying to save
those lives."
- U.S. Must 'Rally' Other Nations The New York Times urges,
"Washington is doing better than other donors, providing badly needed
helicopters for rescue and supply missions, prefabricated bridges and
more than $70 million in relief and resettlement funds. It should be
rallying other countries, as well as private organizations and
individuals, to do their fair share. But surely this country, as the
richest donor with the greatest strategic interest in Pakistan, could do
a lot more right now."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.
User Comments
Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register