Egypt's Bloodshed Dampens Optimism For the Future

Reuters
Ted Mann 1,744 Views Oct 15, 2011

The Egyptian military's shift to the side of protesters helped swing the momentum in that country this spring, and bring down former President Hosni Mubarak. But as the military consolidates power, and wields it, the liberal movement that once celebrated their partnership is growing wary.

The worries grew after the military crushed a protest one week ago, killing 20 Christian demonstrators and adding to doubts about one of the seemingly stable pillars of Egyptian society.

From the Associated Press:

A broader sector of the public has been thrown into shocked confusion. Many Egyptians view the military as the last bastion of stability — a force “made up of our own sons,” as many often say — and tend to trust it to handle the transition toward a democratic system. So images of army troops wildly running over protesters with armored vehicles have jolted them.

Some try to find excuses for the ruling junta or nervously defend it. Intertwined in the reaction are the religious tensions between Egypt’s Muslim majority and Christian minority. The fact that victims were Christians has made some less sympathetic or more willing to forgive the army’s actions.

Others have been so shocked they have joined the criticism.

“This was an awful failure,” said Mohammed Othman, a former army officer who now works as a pharmacist. “I think the (generals) lost credit and now we are in the countdown for them to leave.”

They aren't the only ones gone skeptical. The strong-man-like tactics are losing faith of Western commentators. See, for example, The Wall Street Journal.

The blame for this and most of the recent upheavals rests with the military—not the Muslim Brotherhood or the small group of liberals. The council of generals appointed by Mr. Mubarak has ruled Egypt with little accountability or transparency since his fall. The leaderless revolution in Cairo's Tahrir Square left Egypt without an opposition figure with national stature, like a Mandela or Walesa, to lead the transition to democracy. The generals are a poor substitute.

Will change come, again, for Egypt? And at what potentially bloody cost?

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.

Topics:
Related Articles   More by Ted Mann

Saleh's Shrinking Self-Imposed Deadline to Step Down in Yemen

Five Best Thursday Columns

How Occupy Influenced Egypt's Arab Spring (and Vice Versa)

 

Why the iPhone Isn't Building a New U.S. Middle Class

Mitt Romney Will Release His Tax Returns After All

Elsewhere on the Web

User Comments

Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register

  • The Atlantic Wire on Twitter
  • The Atlantic Wire RSS Feed
  • The Atlantic Wire iPhone App