So, How Close Is North Korea to Having a Nuclear Missile, Really?

Scientists and technicians at the General Satellite Control and Command Center on the outskirts of Pyongyang watch the launch of the Unha-3 rocket from a launch site on the west coast, in the village of Tongchang-ri.
AP Photo
Dashiell Bennett 6,035 Views Dec 12, 2012

The headlines all say that North Korea's successful missile launch today brings them one step closer to a nuclear missile, but there are plenty — plenty — more steps to take before they get there. The DPRK launched a two-stage rocket that traveled about 1,600 miles before deploying what its official state news agency enthusiastically called a "satellite" that "successfully entered its preset orbit." That's a significant step for a country dreaming of frightening the globe with a fleet of ballistic missiles — even the South Koreans haven't put anything in orbit by themselves yet — but it's still a far cry from being able to deliver a working nuclear weapon to enemy territory like, say, the West Coast of the United States. There are still a lot of very complex technical hurdles to overcome.

For starters, the missile they launched today might have technically reached space (although Secretary of Defense Leon Panetta is disputing that), but it certainly didn't come back. In order to threaten the U.S. (or most other parts of the world), North Korea's projectile needs to be able to survive re-entry intact, David Sanger explains in The New York Times — and that's a trick the North Koreans have yet to even attempt. It also had no target. Every missile they've fired has either exploded or fallen randomly into the sea. There's no indication that they have the guidance capabilities to hit any specific place with any amount of accuracy. Not that they would need much to hit South Korea or Japan, but that's the other point: North Korea already has weapons that can reach their two biggest rivals, so on that score, today's test doesn't change anything.

Despite the fears of swapping out a harmless payload for a weapon of mass destruction, it's unlikely that the Unha-3 rocket they fired today could even carry one. The satellite that was launched into space weighed only 220 pounds, according to The Times, one-tenth the size of an average nuclear warhead.

Yet even if they solve those problems and graduate to a true intercontinental ballistic missile with real range and deadly accuracy, they still have to a put a nuclear bomb on it, which is of course no small feat in itself. North Korea has only conducted two nuclear weapons tests in its history. The first, in 2006, produced a 0.2 -kiloton explosion, a far cry from the 15-kiloton bomb that had to be dropped from a plane on Hiroshima — and would itself be considered puny by today's weapons standards. They tested a second one in 2009, but it wasn't much larger. There is speculation that North Korea will perform a nuke test again soon, but their nuclear program is still not as advanced as it needs to be. 

They've only just begun to master the technology behind nuclear weapons, and there's a big leap from setting off an explosion underground to a working bomb that can be hurled halfway around the globe and exploded on target. They have the uranium to build bombs and the know-how to set them off, but making them small enough to put on a rocket and control them from afar just isn't in the cards right now. 

Pretty much every expert agrees that North Korea doesn't have a weapon capable of being placed on a missile, and they still don't have a missile that can be fired across an ocean. When and if they do, they need the sophistication and tools to putting all the pieces together and make it work as one cohesive weapon delivery system. For a nation with North Korea's size and limited resources, that remains a pretty tall order.

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at dbennett at theatlantic dot com. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.

Related Articles   More by Dashiell Bennett

North Korea Agrees to Stop Enriching Uranium, Scaring the World with Missiles

North Korean officials attend a national meeting to celebrate the 71st birth anniversary of North Korea's late leader Kim Jong-il at Pyongyang Indoor Stadium in Pyongyang February 15, 2013. The birth anniversary of the late leader Kim falls on Saturday.

North Korea's Nuclear Negotiating Game Has It All Backwards

North Korea Just Aimed Its Rockets at U.S. Bases

 

Berlin Looks a Lot Different to Obama in 2013 Than It Did in 2008

A piece of debris from TWA flight 800 floats in the Atlantic Ocean off Long Island, N.Y. in this July 18, 1996 file photo.

TWA Flight 800 Investigators Claim the Official Crash Story Is a Lie

Elsewhere on the Web

User Comments

Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register

  • The Atlantic Wire on Twitter
  • The Atlantic Wire RSS Feed
  • The Atlantic Wire iPhone App