Six deaths in six months have aroused intense concern about student suicide at Cornell University. As Cornell students, professors,
administrators, and alums seek explanations for the wave, the big question both on campus and off is this: to what extent are Ithaca's famed and
beautiful gorges, into which these students are flinging themselves, a
part of the problem?
- Maybe the Gorges Really Are an Issue Rob Fishman
Cornell alum and current Associate Blog Editor at The Huffington Post,
posts an excerpted, adapted version of some of his masters degree work
on the Cornell suicides. Though it's commonly said that suicidal
persons, barred from a bridge, will simply turn elsewhere to end their
lives, he points to a study showing that this isn't actually true:
"Richard H. Seiden, then a professor at Berkeley, tracked down 515
people who attempted suicide but were restrained. His findings showed
that 90 percent of the would-be victims did not later die of later
suicide attempts, and that the notion that 'attempters will surely and
inexorably "just go someplace else," is clearly unsupported by the
- Yes, Easy Access Is a Factor "There is evidence," Gawker's Maureen O'Connor
reminds readers, "that the availability of impulsive suicide methods
increases the likelihood of successful attempts." She reviews Cornell's
new "suicide prevention efforts," including a mental health campaign,
caution in how the deaths are discussed, and putting guards on the
gorge bridges. "All three strategies are wise," she says, but "don't
underestimate the third one."
- Students, Don't Look at the Gorges Cornell history professor Joseph Palermo,
notes that Ithaca, where there's little to do but work and mourn the
loss of sun, "can be a very, very depressing place." He also writes of
students, when a suicide occurs, "[knowing] exactly the kind of forces
that could push someone to that point. But it's the gorges, even with
their beauty, that make it happen so readily. It's just too easy," he
says. His instructions for Cornell students:
brutal months of March and April ... go to the Chapter House or to
Rulloff's or the Nines join your friends and drink lots of beer and eat
pizza and chicken wings and listen to live music every night after
you're done studying for your exams and writing your papers. Then go
home and crawl into bed. Don't even take a peek at those gorges when
you're crossing over them.
- 'There Never Really Is a Satisfying Explanation,' writes Cornell law professor William Jacobson,
"when a young person commits suicide." But he thinks it's time for some
self-examination in society and at Cornell. "We need to do a better job
helping students keep life in perspective. We place so much pressure on
our young people to achieve at an early age."
- All of Us Need to Do More "We must be one another's support system," write the editors of The Cornell Daily Sun,
the campus newspaper. "The real issues must be faced on a day-to-day
basis within our community, and they must be faced proactively ... We
have to be vigilant for those we do not know." They mention the effect
of academic pressure.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.