The Catholic abuse scandal
just keeps getting bigger. As more information comes to light about the pope's involvement in abuse coverups--the New York Times
follows yesterday's astounding story on the Wisconsin cases
with more evidence of the pope's involvement in a Munich case
--questions about the Catholic church's response are growing. As Choire Sicha
of irreverant blog The Awl puts it, echoing the thoughts of many: "So the very head of the Catholic Church
is directly implicated in multiple coverups of and inaction regarding
child abuse. Whatever do we think the Church will do?" Good question.
Many are beginning to call for the pope's removal or resignation--the
Wire covered Andrew Sullivan's dramatic piece
on the subject here
are those really possibilities? Here's the guide to the debate over what's possible, what's plausible, and what's necessary.
- Resignation as Penance In a letter to The Independent, Maureen McCulloch
writes of learning, as a young Catholic, that confession is "essential
but not sufficient" for absolution of sin. "One had to have serious
repentance, and could demonstrate this (to God, oneself and others) by
doing penance." What does that mean here? "Cardinal Brady should resign
and hand himself to the authorities in Ireland. Pope Benedict should do
the same in Germany and all the others who were part of this terrible
affair all over the world should examine their consciences and follow
suit." It's not about blame but about "these men as devout Catholics,
by examining their own consciences, seeing that they have sinned and
realising that they need to do penance. They don't need me, or anyone
else, to tell them that."
- 'Full Criminal Investigation of the
Vatican' That's what self-identified Catholic singer Sinead O'Connor
is calling for, interviewed by Henry Chu in the L.A. Times. She doesn't specifically mention resignation.
- The Definitive Guide to Getting Rid of the Pope (Summary: It's Really Hard) Slate's Christopher Beam
gets down to business. The pope cannot be removed from
office--"according to church law, there is no higher authority than the
pope." Nor can the pope be prosecuted under secular law--he has
immunity with regard to local law, and for the purposes of
international law is also immune, as he is considered a head of state.
Clearly, there have been exceptions to "the sovereign-immunity rule,"
but Slobodan Milosevic isn't likely to serve as a precedent for dealing
with the pope. Technically, continues Beam, once heads of state leave
office, they can be prosecuted for crimes committed before they took
office (before the immunity period began)--but "the pope almost never
retires." The one option open:
A pope may resign, but his
resignation must be "made freely," and he doesn't have to tender his
resignation to any particular authority. (The last pope to resign was
Gregory XII, who did so in 1415 to end the battle for the papacy known
as the Western schism.)
- Don't Expect a Resignation "Inevitably," writes the Guardian's Madeleine Bunting,
"people ask dramatic questions such as can the pope survive, can the
Catholic church survive? No pope has resigned for centuries," she
states flatly. "The pope is likely to stagger on, the prestige of his
office much battered."
- No Joke--Look at the History, adds Mary Ann Sorrentino,
who has a long adversarial relationship with the Catholic hierarchy--a
Catholic, she was excommunicated for her directorship of the Rhode
Island chapter of Planned Parenthood.
The church has a
long history of protecting its pontiffs, even when they've ordered
killings, allowed the faithful to be slaughtered, fathered illegitimate
children, stolen and worse ... Short of the unlikely revival of the
feudal tradition (rumored to have been used last on Pope John Paul I)
in which pontiffs making waves might be poisoned (or tossed in the
Tiber, or fatally injured by an arranged fall off their horse),
Ratzinger will be pope until his natural death. The brutal politics of
Rome make anything inside Washington's Beltway -- or in the darkest
political reaches of Iran, Russia or Beijing -- look benign by
- Resignation Isn't the Worst that Can Happen "The danger," writes Catholic David Gibson
at Politics Daily, "is not so much that the pope will resign--that
won't happen," he agrees, "and maybe can't happen, under the church's
arcane rules and traditions." Rather, he continues, "the real risk is
that with new reports of his own record emerging seemingly daily ...
the bishop of Rome, despite the aura and authority of his
office--handed down from St. Peter himself--will begin to look like
every other bishop these days." That's bad for the Church, Gibson says.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.