"It has been fashionable to affirm that all religions are beautiful and all are true," writes Boston University religion professor Stephen Prothero
in the Boston Globe. In fact, many feel-good declarations often take it a step further:
"Even the Dalai Lama, who should know better, has gotten into the act,
claiming that 'all major religious traditions carry basically the same
message.'" That's just not true, says Prothero. More than that, it's
The gods of Hinduism are not the same as the
orishas of Yoruba religion or the immortals of Daoism. To pretend that
they are is to refuse to take seriously the beliefs and practices of
ordinary religious folk who for centuries have had no problem
distinguishing the Nicene Creed of Christianity from the Four Noble
Truths of Buddhism from the Shahadah of Islam. It is also to lose sight
of the unique beauty of each of the world’s religions.
practical sense, too, assuming all religions are ultimately the same is
"dangerous," argues Prothero:
"How can we make sense of the ongoing
conflict in Kashmir if we pretend that Hinduism and Islam are one and
the same? Or of the impasse in the Middle East, if we pretend that
there are no fundamental disagreements between Judaism, Christianity,
It's great that many now reject "the exclusivist
missionary view that only you and your kind will make it to heaven or
nirvana or paradise," he writes, but we must acknowledge that
"each of the world's religions looks to different exemplars," and have
different "techniques they employ to take you from problem to goal."
Varying beliefs in salvation, reincarnation, and enlightenment likewise
demand different ways of approaching life. In this sense, "what the
world's religions share is not so much a finish line as a starting
point. And where they begin is with this simple observation: Something
is wrong with the world."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.