The controversy surrounding Park 51, a Muslim community center to be built two blocks from Ground Zero, gained renewed currency this weekend.
On Friday, President Obama appeared to support the center's organizers,
saying "Muslims have the right to practice their religion as everyone
else in this country." However, on Saturday, Obama clarified his
remarks. "I was not commenting and I will not comment on the wisdom of
making the decision to put a mosque there," he said. "I was commenting
very specifically on the right people have that dates back to our
founding." Pouncing on the issue, House Minority Leader John Boehner called
Obama's apparent support of the center "deeply troubling." With national
leaders of both parties weighing in on the subject, one thing's clear:
the so-called '9/11 Mosque' controversy isn't going anywhere:
- This Issue Just Went National, writes Reid Wilson
at Hotline: "Obama and Boehner don't often work together. But this
weekend, the 2 combined to make sure the so-called Ground Zero Mosque
leaps from the cable news triumvirate to the editorial pages of every
local paper. While Obama's comments drew near-universal praise from his
base... that's not something an endangered Dem congressman in the middle
of the country wants to read when he or she picks up the Sunday paper."
- Republicans See a Political Opportunity, writes Ben Smith and Maggie Haberman
at Politico: "The harsh Republican response to President Barack Obama's
defense of a mosque near ground zero marks a dramatic shift in the
party's posture toward Islam— from a once active courtship of Muslim
voters to a very public tolerance after Sept. 11 to an openly aired
sense of mistrust. Republican leaders have largely abandoned former
President George W. Bush's post-Sept. 11 rhetorical embrace of American
Muslims and his insistence — always controversial inside the party —
that Islam is a religion of peace. This weekend, former Bush aides were
among the very few Republicans siding with Obama, as many of the party's
leaders have moved toward more vocal denunciations of Islam's role in
violence abroad and suspicion of its place at home."
- Obama's Speech Was Very Clintonian, writes Byron York
at the Washington Examiner: "There is simply no doubt that Obama's
Friday evening speech, in the context in which it was delivered, was an
endorsement of the Ground Zero project... But on Saturday, Obama said
all those listeners were wrong, that they misunderstood him. Several
years ago, there was a word for Obama's rhetorical technique:
Clintonian. Like the former president, Obama spoke words he knew would
be understood as having a particular meaning in a particular context. He
also knew that those same words, when examined closely outside that
context, might also be interpreted as having a different meaning. In
that sense, the mosque affair is a good lesson for both supporters and
opponents of the president. From now on, with Obama, as it was with
Clinton, the rule is: Don't listen to the speech. Read the words very
carefully."
- This Is a Winning Issue for Democrats, writes Jonathan Chait
in The New Republic: "I think this will pay long-term political
dividends for Democrats. There's a classic pattern of Democrats
cementing the allegience of minority groups by standing up for them when
those groups sit outside the mainstream culture, and thus when there's a
real political price to defending them. Fifty years from now, Muslims
will be voting heavily Democratic because they'll remember that Obama
defended their rights when it was unpopular to do so. Of course that
won't help Obama, but it's impressive to see him stand on principle.
Bush could have taken this position without suffering politically. Obama
doesn't have that luxury."
- Obama Is Wrong on This, says Democrat Jeff Green,
who is running for the U.S. Senate in Florida: "President Obama has
this all wrong and I strongly oppose his support for building a mosque
near Ground Zero. Freedom of religion might provide the right to build
the mosque in the shadow of Ground Zero, but common sense and respect
for those who lost their lives and loved ones gives sensible reason to
build the mosque someplace else. President Obama had the chance to show
leadership by calling on the mosque's supporters to find a more
appropriate location."
- How Do You Know What 9/11 Victims Want? questions Michael Kinsley
at The Atlantic Wire: "Presumably the 9/11 families don't speak in
unison. Some of them, of course, are Muslims. Others may be liberals or
even card-carrying ACLU members. (This was New York after all.) Some may
actually like the idea of a Muslim center radiating ecumenical vibes
right near Ground Zero. Is there any reason that the wishes of these
victims should be trumped by the wishes of other victims?"
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
jhudson at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.
User Comments
Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register