A new tumblr getting attention today asks the question on every Brooklyn-goer's mind: Halloween or Williamsburg? There's no shortage of Tumblrs that engage in light-hearted hipster-bashing but halloweenorwilliamsburg.tumblr.com gets points for putting a timely twist on the sport. The Tumblr's been around for a few days now, but it was discovered and passed around enough on Tuesday that it's now trending on Twitter. Creators take advantage of the Brooklyn neighborhood's reputation for housing absurdly dressed hipsters. Viewers can submit photos that leave ambiguous whether we are looking at a picture of someone dressed up for Halloween or just another Williamsburg resident, and honestly, we have some trouble deciding on nearly all of them. We'll leave you to cast your own judgement. 

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at erandall at theatlantic dot com. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.