A Penn Service Announcement: It's Not Penn State

UTB/PennBookstore
Rebecca Greenfield 12,863 Views Nov 9, 2011

This morning New York Times columnist Maureen Dowd made a mistake that has Ivy Leaguers in a tizzy: she referred to Penn State as Penn. The University of Pennsylvania's blog, Under the Button promptly noticed the error and posted a rejoinder: "Hey Maureen Dowd, We’re Not Penn State." Wrote Penn blogger Morgan Finkelstein: "Homegirl is seriously trashing our reputation! ... The mistake has been corrected on the Times' website, but seriously, world, stop confusing us with the brouhaha at Penn State." Dowd was not alone. Out on the West Coast, the Contra Costa Times and L.A.'s The Daily Breeze both ran the headline on an A.P. report: "Official Says Support for Penn's Paterno Eroding." It's a mixup that Penn students and alumni are rather sensitive about. When the scandal broke earlier this week, for example, Mother Jones intern and Penn alum Aaron Ross tweeted "I'm not usually a fan, but those 'not Penn State' T-shirts might be useful now."

The Not Penn State confusion is not a new phenomenon, Penn students are always getting in a tizzy over being confused for the "less prestigious" state school, because, like Finkelstein said, it totally ruins Penn's smarty pants reputation. This time Penn probably doesn't appreciate the association with sex-offenders, but this Penn State sensitivity existed before Joe Paterno's dirty deeds came to light. The Penn v. Penn State confusion happens all the time. That same blog that pointed out the error has a whole section of Penn State blunders. Forever 21 made a similar mistake calling its Penn shirt the Pennsylvania State University Contrast Tee, for example. The school's official bookstore even sells this embarrassing "Not Penn State" T-shirt that Ross tweeted about. It's kind of a school joke and sore spot. 

Like we said, the sensitivity is not just about sexual assault, it's about an Ivy League inferiority complex coupled with the Penn State athletic superiority complex. Penn doesn't have the same name recognition as its Ivy League brethren, even though -- and Penn students will be extremely quick to tell you this -- it ranks higher than the better-known Cornell and Brown. The Penn State confusion only makes things worse. Not only has nobody heard of Penn, people think it's some state school. Penn kids hate that.

(Full disclosure: This writer went to Penn but has never owned a Not Penn State T-shirt.)

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at rgreenfield at theatlantic dot com. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.

Related Articles   More by Rebecca Greenfield

Penn State's McQueary Kept off the Sideline by Threats

Penn State Removes Paterno Statue, Faces Huge Penalties From NCAA

Joe Paterno Has Lung Cancer

 

3 Fun & Easy Tips for Spending Your 2013 Memorial Day BBQ... with Cicadas

iPhone's New iOS7 Design Is Flat as Hell and You Can't Stand the Wait Anymore

Elsewhere on the Web

User Comments

Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register

  • The Atlantic Wire on Twitter
  • The Atlantic Wire RSS Feed
  • The Atlantic Wire iPhone App