CNBC's Darren Rovell Shows How Not to Crowdsource a Story

Robert Neff, via Flickr
Dashiell Bennett 824 Views Jun 6, 2012

CNBC's sports business reporter Darren Rovell has been victimized by a devious prankster, who tricked him into reporting something that wasn't true. But it's his response to getting played that raises even more questions about the meaning journalistic integrity. 

The short version of the story, as reported by Deadspin's John Koblin, goes likes this: Back in November, Rovell asked his readers for stories about how the NBA lockout was affecting their business over Twitter. A bored high-school kid wrote to him pretending to be a pimp (sorry, the head of an "escort service") who caters to NBA players and celebrity fans. After several back and forth emails, Rovell took the writer at his word and dropped a note into his story that the escort service had lost about 30 percent of its business. He also used that tidbit as a teaser when tweeting the story out. Obviously, everything the so-called "pimp" he told Rovell was a lie.

Rovell was done in by two classic journalism mistakes. The first, less obvious one, is that crowdsourcing is a lousy way to gather news. As Rovell himself suggests in his CNBC mea culpa prompted by Koblin's report, people will say almost anything if they think it might end up in print, and people you don't know and never meet can't really be trusted. It happens to lots of people, because it's very tempting to rely on these kinds of tips. The information comes so easily, but it needs to be taken with twice the amount of salt. The second is a more traditional maxim: If a story is too good to check, it probably isn't true.

Unfortunately, Rovell's takeaway from being had is that if a story is too good to check ... he won't even bother trying anymore. While he takes full blame for being duped and offers up a sincere-sounding apology, his ultimate response is to punish his readers for the sins of his lying source. Here's how he ends his apology:

As a result I will do fewer stories on the real life impact of big events which I do think the public enjoys.

There will always be people out there who want their 15 minutes of fame and not really care how they get there. 

So his solution to not doing enough reporting is... To do less reporting. That'll teach his lying source a lesson. 

Photo: Robert Neff/Fifth World Art via Flickr

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at dbennett at theatlantic dot com. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.

Related Articles   More by Dashiell Bennett

What Does It Mean That the Majority of ASME Finalists Are Men?

New York Times Devours Gothamist

Arianna Huffington vs. Rupert Murdoch

 
Police officers stand guard in front of Notre Dame Cathedral, in Paris, Tuesday, May 21, 2013. Notre Dame has been evacuated after a man committed suicide in the 850-year-old monument and tourist attraction.

Right-Wing Activist Commits Suicide Inside Notre Dame Cathedral

Bye Bye Belly Putting

Elsewhere on the Web

User Comments

Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register

  • The Atlantic Wire on Twitter
  • The Atlantic Wire RSS Feed
  • The Atlantic Wire iPhone App