Liberal Democrats may be "set to go it alone" on the proposal for health care public option, reports
the New York Times. Indeed, the more progressive members of Congress are beginning to actively battle
the White House, threatening "100 votes
if the public option is dropped. Progressive pundits are rallying,
calling for ignoring Republicans, going to war with conservative
Democrats, pushing the White House to the left, or simply taking over
- Questioning Bipartisanship Salon's Alex Koppelman asked,
Why are Dems still negotiating on health care? "Are negotiations worth
it? Or, with Democrats firmly in control of both
houses of Congress, can they write further concessions off as a
lose-lose proposition?" he wondered. "There's the question of what has
actually been gained by the moves towards bipartisanship that have been
made thus far."
- Countering Blue Dogs FireDogLake's Jane Hamsher has written
of the conservative Democrats, "Blue Dogs are 'on the other side of
the aisle.' And everyone but Rahm seems to know it." Hamsher later wrote
of more liberal Dems, "Thanks to the progressive members of the House
who have pledged to
vote against any health care bill that does not have a public plan.
They represent 76% of Americans who want a public plan, and coming from
heavily Democratic-leaning districts as they do, an even greater
percentage of their own constituents."
Greg Sargent of the Plum Line wrote of progressive Dems, "In a sense this gives them an opportunity. House liberals, who
perpetually complain that the Blue Dogs’ concerns are doted over by the
White House and leadership, have a chance to do as the Blue Dogs do:
Lay down their marker and refuse to budge."
- Opportunity for Hard Line Chris Bowers of Open Left noted, "Progressives have consistently proven more willing to fold than Blue
Dogs and / or Conservadems. Given this, the White House is simply
pressuring what recent history has shown to be the more easily
pressured group when it needs to pass legislation," he wrote. "Well, we have to change this dynamic once and for all."
MSNBC host Rachel Maddow, ever the cynic, could barely believe it.
"Democrats drawing a line in the sand against conservatives in their
own party. Democrats playing hardball from the progressive side," she
said. "Pinch me. I'm dreaming"
- Progressives Running the Show Mike Lux argued
in the Huffington Post that progressive Dems have more power than they
think, especially in pushing for a public option. Lux laid out several
detailed scenarios for progressive to push through a public option
without Republican or Blue Dog support. "The media and establishment
conventional wisdom, which always tends
toward the dire and toward the conservative scenarios, is sometimes
proven wrong," he wrote. "So ye of little faith, do not give up hope."
Digby encouraged progressives to push all they want, reasoning that if reform fails it's
Obama and the Blue Dogs who are going to suffer. "They're toast if
there's no health care reform anyway, because Dems are going to suffer
big losses with Obama's failure and they
will be the ones who lose their seats," she wrote. "It's not like the Republicans
are going to go easy on Blue Dogs in swing districts out of the
goodness of their hearts. It's the New Blue Dogs who are tied
to Obama's coat tails, not the liberals who are in safe seats."
- Nothing But Political Noise MSNBC's
Chuck Todd, on last night's Hardball, pointed out that the progressives
making so much hay over the public option may be playing politics and
ignoring actual policy goals. "The left, the people that are most up in
arms on the public option don't understand what they're even for when
it comes to the public [option]," Todd said, summarizing the White
House position. "So the White House is trying to preach patience here
and saying, Hey, hold on a minute. Maybe the co-ops is going to be able
to do what you want it to do on the public option. But you need to be
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.