Joe Wilson raised quite a ruckus
by accusing Obama of lying, but Washington Post columnist Charles Krauthammer is the first to seriously consider
the charge. Does Obama lie? Is he trustworthy? Two liberals and a reporter rebut Krauthammer's verdict.
- An Eliding, Truth-Telling Liar Charles Krauthammer conceded
that Obama didn't lie, but went on to describe lots of very
dishonest-sounding behavior. "He merely elides, gliding from one
dubious assertion to another," he wrote. "This
has been the story throughout his whole health-care crusade. Its
original premise was that our current financial crisis was rooted in
neglect of three things — energy, education and health care. That
transparent attempt to exploit Emanuel’s Law — a crisis is a terrible
thing to waste — failed for health care because no one is stupid enough
to believe that the 2008 financial collapse was caused by a lack of
universal health care."
- 'Krauthammer Projects His Dishonesty Onto Obama' Charged Jonathan Chait of the New Republic. "Krauthammer implies that Obama is relying on a vague promise to cut
waste, fraud and abuse, which is a classic political dodge," Chait wrote. "In fact,
Obama is referring to specific cuts that have been scored by the
Congressional Budget Office. Does Krauthammer wish to challenge the
CBO's findings? Of course not. He just wants to cast doubt upon Obama's
plan by picking up any available weapon."
- Americans Believe Obama Mark Silva of the Chicago Tribune pointed out poll data that shows most Americans trust Obama. "For all the 'TelePrompTer President' criticism
that Obama draws from detractors, eight in 10 Americans say he is a
good communicator," Silva wrote. "And nearly two-thirds of those surveyed by the Pew Research Center
say that Obama is trustworthy. A similar number view him as a strong
leader, according to the survey of 1,006 adults conducted Sept. 10-15."
- Krauthammer is Obsessed with Clinton A Daily Kos contributor made a mocking parody of Krauthammer. "Obama doesn't lie," he quoted from Krauthammer. "He communicates. Joe Wilson hates that, so let me defend Wilson. And
while I defend Wilson, let me bring up everything I hated about
Clinton, because he communicated, too. And that mofo won a second term."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.