On Tuesday, the Senate Finance Committee voted down
versions of a "public option" for government insurance as part of its health care reform legislation. The
Finance Committee is just one of several committees handling health care legislation (the others have approved a
public option), but because it is the most conservative it is thought to hold
special importance. Despite Democrats' 13-10 majority on the Finance Committee, the failed votes came as no surprise, since several conservative Democrats, including the chairman Max Baucus, oppose a public option. Several prominent liberals were nevertheless angry that their own
party brought about the defeat. With lightning-rod liberals like Michael Moore and Howard Dean getting increasingly vocal in their criticism of moderate
Democrats, the threat of a circular firing squad is growing.
- Moderates Dems Imperil Party's Majority Howard Dean told Rachel Maddow
that Democrats who voted against the public option have imperiled the whole party. "Look, here's the problem with
these guys, they're stuck. In the more conservative states, there's a
lot of venom against it, even though the majority of people want it.
And a lot of these guys have taken millions of dollars from the health
insurance industry and they're stuck. And that's a real problem," he
said. "If we don't pass this thing, we're going to lose a lot of
seats. And if we don't pass -- everybody in America now knows that
without a public option, this thing is a farce."
- 'We Will Work Against You' Michael Moore threatened recalcitrant Democrats that they would become targets of
the left. "To the Democrats in Congress who don’t quite get it: I want
to offer a
personal pledge. I – and a lot of other people – have every intention
of removing you from Congress in the next election if you stand in the
way of health care legislation that the people want," he said. "That is
not a hollow or idle threat. We will come to your district and
we will work against you, first in the primary and, if we have to, in
the general election."
- Bipartisan-Minded Dems are Unwitting Tools of GOP Ezra Klein knocked moderate Dems
who, he says, are inadvertently helping
Republicans kill reform by fetishizing the idea of bipartisanship. "Baucus and Conrad did the work for them,
all the while
protesting that they didn't oppose the public option," he wrote. "Now
bloc will need to extract something else in an eleventh-hour
bargain to show that they applied their centrist convictions to the
legislation. Baucus makes it sound as though he's attempting to ensure
a deal. But in reality, he's just depriving the centrists of the
ability to make their deal. That means they'll have to make a different
one, and the bill will get worse twice rather than once."
- The Ruse of Bipartisanship Digby slammed moderate Dems
who, unlike Jay Rockefeller, voted against a public option designed to help their middle-class constituents. "Considering the bipartisan
whorishness of our current political system,
it's almost a guarantee that there there won't be the kind of
regulation needed to give security to average people," she wrote. "I
think Blanche Lincoln, Kent Conrad and Max Baucus all have plenty of
constituents who make 30k a year just like Rockefeller. But they'd
rather see them suffer than risk being called a socialist by some
confused teabagger or lose a big campaign check from Blue Cross. It's a
choice. And what they choose tells you a whole lot about the character
of those making it."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.