The Democrats' health care bill passed in the House last weekend, but not without a last-minute amendment banning federal funds from subsidizing abortions. Now explosive
divisions over the Stupak Amendment threaten to derail the bill in the Senate. Despite a warning to Democrats from former President Bill Clinton
Tuesday that the "the worst thing to do is nothing," a number of key lawmakers from both camps appear unwilling to compromise on the amendment. Can the health care bill survive the abortion debate?
- Democratic Waterloo At Red State, Dan McLaughlin thinks the bill is looking less and less likely to pass because of divisions within the Democratic Party. He also argues that abortion isn't the only issue in the health care bill dividing Democrats.
The political reality remains: there may not be enough votes to
pass the final bill with the Stupak Amendment, because of intransigence
from pro-choice Democrats, and there may not be enough votes to pass
the final bill without the Stupak Amendment, because of intransigence
from pro-life Democrats. And that's even before we get to the fissures
among the Democrats and with the public at large over taxes, spending,
individual mandates, the public option, tort reform, immigration, and
- No Easy Way Out For Dems The Politico's Alexander Burns says "the sudden spasm of intense debate over abortion on Capitol Hill this week threatens not only to stall the passage of health care legislation, but also to shatter the delicate cease-fire that has governed the abortion issue during the Obama era." In Burns's mind, Democrats only have two choices if the bill is going to pass, and both of them entail losses.
"After months of dodging high-profile confrontations over abortion, Democrats --
including President Barack Obama -- find themselves faced with a stark
set of alternatives: Support a bill that imposes limits on access to
abortion or demand one that might, however indirectly, fund the
procedure with taxpayer money."
- Good Old Party Dysfunction Joe Weisenthal of The Business Insider says "the Democratic party has returned to form, re-establishing its
reputation as one big circular firing squad, incapable of being the
- Liberals Will Swallow The Bitter Pill At Newsweek, Katie Connolly says pro-choice Democrats aren't likely to do anything to kill health care reform, even if it means voting for the Stupak amendment. "After
Saturday's historic win for health-care reform in the House, it seems
deeply unlikely liberals will throw a year's worth of legislative
work─and decades of effort─on the trash heap over this issue. Moderates
on the other hand, don't seem to share those qualms."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mgay at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.