The rising suicide rate in the U.S. armed forces is a harrowing problem
all-too-familiar to those close to the military. This year has been the worst for suicides since the Army began recording data in
1980, with 147 suspected cases--up from 140 last year. Why are these deaths spiking, and what can be done?
- Too Many Deployments Time's Daniel Mihailescu reports, "Although Army officials don't blame the spike on repeated deployments
to war zones, evidence is mounting to the contrary. Only about a third
of Army suicides happen in war zones, officials note, and another third
are among personnel who had never deployed. But that means two-thirds
of Army suicides have deployed, many returning home with mental scars
that make them prone to take their own lives, the Army's No. 2 officer
said last week." He also explores the use of prescription drugs. "A recent Army study shows that the percentage of soldiers in
Afghanistan taking antidepressants and other mental-health drugs nearly
tripled -- from 3.5% to 9.8% -- between their first and third
Increase Dwell Time! Veteran Voice's Jon Soltz writes
in the Huffington Post that the "dwell time" -- the time troops get
home between deployments, which has been reduced -- must be restored.
This is "not what our soldiers deserve as their suicide rate increases
levels for the fourth year in a row. Not when the Army itself says
there's a "significant link" between length of deployments and
suicides. Even if the Obama administration doesn't use Stop Loss or
increase deployments lengths to make their Afghanistan deployment
schedule work, it's clear our soldiers need more of a break between
- Complex With Many Causes U.S. Army Vice Chief of Staff, Gen. Peter Chiarelli explains the challenges to CNN. "We still haven't found any statistically significant causal linkage
that would allow us to effectively predict human behavior. The reality
is there is no simple answer, each suicide case is as unique as the
individuals themselves," he said. "Everywhere I try to cut this and look at it to try to find out what the
causal effect is, I get thwarted. And that's why we think that we've
got to look in its totality at a whole bunch of different issues, and
it's going to take time."
- 'Our Deadliest Enemy' Official Military.com blogger Jamie McIntyre worries. "From my years of covering military suicide rates, I know that
traditionally the military rate is lower than for civilians, once
you adjust for age, gender, etc. But because civilian statistics
are not as current, we can't tell how much worse the situation may
be in the military. Still we know something's wrong when more of our fighting men and
women are dying by their own hand than from the Taliban or al Qaeda."
- As Dangerous As Iraq Talking Points Memo's David Kurtz does the math.
"The 140 Army suicides so far this year equal the total from all of
2008 -- and almost equal the 142 U.S. troops from all the services
killed in Iraq so far this year." That was in November. As of today,
the number of Americans killed in Iraq in 2009 is 151.
- Suicide Among Inactive Army High NBC News's Jim Miklaszewski and Courtney Kube note "another 71 Army National Guard and Army Reserve soldiers who were NOT
deployed at the time of death are also possible or confirmed suicide
victims." They write, "Of course, with so many Guard and Reserve soldiers serving in Iraq and
Afghanistan, a soldier could be back from the war zone for only a
matter of weeks before being inactivated."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.