The Senate's 1 a.m. vote, which showed that Democrats may have finally secured the votes
to pass health care reform, turned on the votes of two men: Senators Ben Nelson
and Joe Lieberman
Nelson, a conservative Democrat from Nebraska, and Lieberman, a
conservative Democrat-turned-Independent from Connecticut, long opposed
the bill. To appease them, Democrats drove the legislation to the right
over the last few weeks. Now that Nelson and Lieberman have come around,
health care watchers are divided. Are the two Senators heroes for
finally joining with Democratic leadership to pass historic
legislation? Or are they villains who abused their position to exert
undue influence on the legislative process?
- The 'Grifter Politicians' New York Daily News's Mike Lupica is disgusted.
politicians Ben Nelson, Joe Lieberman do number on health care
reform bill," he headlines his story. "You could call people like this
the brand new Washington generation of
the boys of Tammany Hall, except that in another New York, Tammany Hall
was actually known for providing services, starting with jobs. [...]
Something else separates Tammany Hall from the current U.S. Senate. In
old New York, they did their skimming out in the open and never tried
to pretend they were doing something noble."
- An 'Achievable' Compromise The Washington Post's Ezra Klein isn't sweating it. "A smart observer told me that the bill would come down to whether Ben
Nelson, in his heart of hearts, wanted to vote for it or wanted to use
his demands to kill it. It looks like he wanted to vote for it.
Nelson's compromises were achievable. Abortion language stronger than
what the legislation had but considerably weaker than what [House Democrat and pro-life advocate] Bart Stupak
preferred. An extra year of federal funding for the Medicaid expansion,
which is probably a good thing one way or the other."
- Nelson's Bribe Won't Last Senate-watchers of all ideological stripes are furious with Nelson, whose vote was won in part with a $100 million provision specific to Nelson's home state of Nebraska, dubbed the "Cornhusker Kickback." Matthew Yglesias blasts it as
"totally politically unsustainable," writing, "The actual amount of
money involved in this is small, but the policy justification is
impossible to find." He shrugs, "The extra federal bucks for Nebraska
aren't scheduled to arrive until 2016. That gives congress tons
of time to repeal Nebraska's special treatment. Given Nelson's pivotal
role in the great health care debate of 2009-2010 he was in a position
to demand whatever he wanted. But he can't stay in that position
consistently for the next seven years."
- 'Shows Our Broken Senate' Gawker's Alex Pareene shakes his head.
"We learned, again, forever, that the Senate is broken. There are 60
votes to pass the bill but no chance of that happening before
Christmas. They had to meet at 1 a.m. in a blizzard to pass a
procedural motion. Do you think a climate bill is happening? Hah. Sure.
Whatever. Olympia Snowe and Susan Collins got everything they asked for
and they voted against it. Lieberman and Nelson promise to attempt to
kill it again if it ends up looking too generous," he writes, "But
christ, the country is pretty broken, right? 2010 is going to be fun! There will be like three more of these year-long soul-destroying battles over every little thing!"
- Disproportionate Influence Twitter user Pourmecoffee notes, "Joe Lieberman was more powerful and relevant to health care legislation than the entire US House of Representatives."
- They Could Still Defect Talking Points Memo's Brian Beutler reports
that the two Senators "reminded reporters that they'd oppose the bill
that emerges from
negotiations with the House if the language changes dramatically,
entrenching the conventional wisdom that the House will have to accept
a final bill that's significantly less progressive than the bill they
passed this fall." Lieberman called the 60 "yes" votes, which will need
to hang together until at least Christmas for the Senate to pass the
bill, "delicately balanced."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.