After Uproar, Considering a Move for New York 9/11 Trial

Max Fisher Jan 29, 2010
New York City Mayor Michael Bloomberg balked earlier this week at the upcoming NYC trial of alleged "Sept. 11 mastermind" Khalid Sheikh Mohammed, raising speculation about whether the Obama administration would back down. Bloomberg and two prominent New York Democrats wanted the site moved. The White House is now considering the possibility of an alternate location for the trial, which has drawn attacks from Republicans who oppose civilian trials for accused terrorists. The administration is just exploring its options at this point, but what does it mean that KSM's trial could be moved outside the city he once helped to attack?
  • Location Isn't That Important  Salon's Glenn Greenwald, a staunch supporter of trying terrorists in civilian court, suggest the White House concede the location change as long as they still make it a civilian trial. "There's no reason KSM trial has to be in NYC if there are good reason for it not to be - the key is that there be a real trial - not where."
  • Trial Should Go Rural  Senator Dianne Feinstein (D-CA) explains the opposition to holding it in New York City. "There are other places to try it in the U.S. that are much more remote, much less a target, and much less a squatting ground for propaganda around the world," she says. "I think the administration should listen to the mayor, listen to the mayor's concern, and, candidly, make a change."
  • Get a Military Commission Instead  National Review's Kathryn Jean Lopez, one of the many conservatives opposing a trial at all and insisting on a military commission instead, suggests how to make that happen. "If they won't go military commission, like they should: Find the most 'progressive' locale. San Francisco? That might prove to be a military commission's last chance." Lopez hopes that moving the trial to a Democrat-friendly city will provoke a similar negative reaction.
  • NYC Best Equipped For Trial  Conservative blogger Allahpundit thinks that, if they have to go with a civilian trial, it should be in New York. "There's no hint that KSM’s being sent back to a military tribunal, only that he may end up being tried in a civilian court not located in New York. Which isn’t entirely smart, by the way: As I said from the very beginning, if there’s any city with the security apparatus in place to deal with threats from jihadbots, it’s my hometown."
  • Military Commissions Not Happening  Fox News White House report Major Garrett thinks military commissions aren't an option. "Military charges against 9/11 plotters have been dropped, ruling out military commissions. No timeline yet to resolve talks on alt NYC site," he tweeted. "W/out military charges, no commissions. Obama still for criminal trials. Unless changes, mil comishs out."

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at mfisher at theatlantic dot com. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.

Sources

Related Articles   More by Max Fisher

Biden to NYC: KSM Trial Won't Cost Much

Best Tweets: Lefty Bloggers Blast Obama's KSM Flip-Flop

Is Obama Backing Down on Terrorist Trials?

 

What's Next for Tunisia?

Guarded Optimism for Iran Nuclear Talks

Elsewhere on the Web

User Comments

Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register

  • The Atlantic Wire on Twitter
  • The Atlantic Wire RSS Feed
  • The Atlantic Wire iPhone App