The Tea Party movement has many detractors. Some call it radical, some dispute its size
say it's dangerous but few deny its growing influence
in the GOP and beyond
. In a recent bout
of commentary, some pundits who dislike, and in some cases loathe, the Tea
Party have marveled at its clout. The latest to join the club is David Brooks
the New York Times' moderate conservative. In his Tuesday column Brooks
says that while he's "not a fan of this movement" it may very well "shape
the coming decade." Here's how Brooks and other Tea Party opponents are
depicting the movement:
- The Most Popular Party in Town, writes Brooks:
"A year ago, the Obama supporters were the passionate ones. Now the tea
party brigades have all the intensity... It is now more popular than
either major party. According to the NBC
News/Wall Street Journal poll, 41 percent of Americans have a positive
view of the tea party movement. Only 35 percent of Americans have a
positive view of the Democrats and only 28 percent have a positive view
of the Republican Party."
- Like 60s Radicals, Tea Party Movement Will Hang Around for Years, writes Bobby Cramer
at The Reaction: "Mr. Brooks is right; the tea-baggers will dominate
the GOP and could make life very difficult for them, but he's whistling
past the graveyard if he thinks it's just for the near term... It will
take just as long for the GOP to shed the likes of the loons like
Michele Bachmann and Dick Armey as it did for the Democrats to go from
Abbie Hoffman to Barack Obama."
- A Genuine Grassroots Vehicle, writes Mark McKinnon at The Daily Beast. McKinnon, a former McCain adviser, once remarked that untamed Tea Party protests were "bad for Republicans" as long as they allowed "freaks" and "right-wing nutballs" to "fill the void" in the absence of leadership. But now he says they could be crucial to GOP success: "Much of the media and most Democrats are dismissive of what is truly a
grassroots movement. But the Tea Party has shown remarkable energy in
its short life span... Their ability to leverage energy behind candidates and policies could
be very similar to what MoveOn.org has accomplished on the left."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
jhudson at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.