President Obama is pinning many of the White House's abortive legislative
hopes to the possibility of bipartisanship. He's planning a televised bipartisan summit
on health care reform, which Republicans are threatening to boycott
. He's also pushing for a job bill with bipartisan support. But GOP obstructionism has recently been at a high
, leading many commentators to wonder if bipartisanship is dead
. If it is, does Obama have a shot? That bipartisanship will fail seems to be the only consensus in Washington these days.
- No: 'Bipartisanship Popular, Compromise Tricky' The Washington Post's Jon Cohen reads the polls,
saying Americans "want the two sides to keep working to pass
comprehensive health-care reform." However, "The sticky part of
widespread desire for compromise is that it's simple to want it from
the other side. About three-quarters of Democrats see the congressional
Republicans as intransigent, while a similar proportion of Republicans
see Obama that way."
- No: But Obama Gets This The New Republic's Jonathan Chait insists
it's all part of a plan. "Obama uses a similar approach toward
Republicans as foreign enemies like the Iranian regime: take them up on
their claim to some shared goal (nuclear disarmament, health care
reform), elide their preferred red herrings, engage them seriously, and
then expose their disingenuousness," he writes.
- No: Scant GOP Cooperation The Washington Post's Ezra Klein reads
the GOP "ransom note" response to Obama's call for bipartisan talks,
which includes a demand to scrap health care. "These are not folks who
concern themselves with the appearance of good faith. The only thing
missing is an obscure riddle that Obama must answer before he can speak
to Mitch McConnell."
- No: Neither Side Really Wants It The New York Times's David Herszenhorn explains.
"Skeptics around Washington are already warning that the summit will be
nothing more than Kabuki theater, allowing each side to grandstand on
television while providing little in the way of substantive debate or
additional understanding for the folks watching back home," he writes.
will ask if Obama's willing to consider an across-the-board tax cut.
He'll say no, because he doesn't think it will create jobs and he knows
it will add significantly to the deficit. Then Republicans will say
they couldn't reach a deal ... Mainstream news will describe Congress
as a partisan pit, and public opinion will begin to turn against the
bill because they think Democrats are forcing legislation through, and
the bill is taking too long to come together, and they don't think it
will work, anyway because the press surrounding the bill will be mostly
negative. Moderate Democrats will get nervous and ask to pare down the
bill, which will probably make it less effective, and months later, if
Democrats actually pass the weak-sauce law, it will necessarily lose
Republicans, alienate independents and frustrate liberals.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.