As the East Coast is deluged with snow for the second time in under a week, climate-change doubting politicos and pundits can't help crowing. The public, too, may be swayed--some say the winter storms could in fact kill what little support
there is left for a climate bill
this year. But liberals, environmental experts, and at least one meteorologist argue this is precisely the wrong conclusion: severe snowstorms, far from undermining the climate change thesis, could actually be further evidence for it.
- 'Irony Abounds,' comments conservative Glenn Reynolds, excerpting a reader's e-mail about a climate change colloquium in Pennsylvania being suspended due to snow.
- Political Backlash "It's going to keep snowing in DC until Al Gore cries 'uncle,'" tweets Senator Jim DeMint (R-SC). The Hill's Alexander Bolton
notes that DeMint isn't the only one responding this way. On top of
reprioritizing due to economic worries, "the paralyzing snowfalls have
made the prospect of winning support for a climate bill this year even
- Don't Be Ridiculous, says progressive blogger Matt Yglesias.
He, like many, points to a lack of snow in Vancouver as the Olympics
draw near. "If you turn your moron filter off, though, you'll see that
unusual weather events all around the world are exactly what you would expect from systemic shifts in the global climate."
- These Snows Are Actually Evidence of Global Warming, confirms meteorologist Jeff Masters at Weather Underground, which The New Republic's environmental blogger Bradford Plumer
picks up on. Masters argues that, in fact, these extreme snowstorms
could support the global warming thesis more than detract from it: "It
is quite possible that the dice have been loaded in favor of more
intense Nor'easters for the U.S. Mid-Atlantic and Northeast, thanks to
the higher levels of moisture present in the air due to warmer global
temperatures." As the climate begins to shift, predictions are that
intense winter storms will become more, rather than less, common in
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
hhorn at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.