You might have thought that when President Obama signed the health
care bill into law on Tuesday, the congressional wrangling
over that bill would be over. Not so. Both houses of
Congress must still pass an agreed-upon bill of sidecar amendments,
which the Senate has pledged to pass through reconciliation. Democrats have
the votes to make this happen, but very late on Wednesday night,
Republicans raised an objection. Two small provisions in
the bill do not pertain to the budget, which means the entire bill
cannot be passed by reconciliation. Democrats say they can remove the
offending lines and proceed, but it's another annoying snag in the year-long health care fight. What is the deal?
Holding It Up The Wall Street Journal's Greg Hitt reports, "One
provision is technical language with no substantive importance, aides
said. The other provision is intended to shield recipients of government
Pell Grants, which benefit low-income college students, from the ebb
and flow of changes in federal spending." The two provisions make up "no
more than 16 lines" in the dictionary-sized bill.
Shutting Down Committees The Huffington Post's Ryan Grim reports that Senate
Republicans are striking back at Democrats by deploying every
obstruction they can. That now includes limiting committee hearings to
two hours and restricting them to specific times of day, shutting down
the Senate's ability to conduct business.
- Even More GOP
Stalls The New York Times' David Herszenhorn recounts,
"Before the discovery of the parliamentary issues, Democrats defeated
more than two dozen Republican amendments or other proposals aimed at
derailing the legislation or making changes that would delay it by
forcing an additional vote in the House."
- Shows Senate,
House Working Together The Atlantic's Marc Ambinder sees
unparalleled cooperation between Democrats after a long year of anything
but. "The thick wall of mistrust that's been erected between the two
chambers thins a bit. The more Democrats work cooperatively, the more
they can get done."
- Makes Procedural Reform More Likely Liberal
blogger Chris Bowers suggests all
the GOP tactics are just ensuring that Democrats
inevitably turn their eyes towards reforming the procedural rules of
Congress. "There is only one way that
this is all going to end. In just a few years, the filibuster will be
abolished, and by the end of the decade there will be a wave of rule
changes that will make the Senate pretty much just like the House."
Basically the culture of the Senate seems to be that everyone in the
minority has the power to completely [mess] things up when they want to,
and that works ok as long as people show a little restraint and only
invoke those powers occasionally. But now the Republicans are going
Galt with grumpy old McCain and shutting down committee meetings along
with everything else. It'd be nice if Dems finally started to
acknowledge that the Greatest Deliberative Body In The History Of The
Multiverse basically sucks and need to be changed.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.