As was recently reported in The New York Times, a number of economists have been drawing links
between a person's physical attributes--such as height, weight, and
attractiveness--and the likelihood that they'll commit crimes. People
who are shorter than average, or heavier, or less likely to be
considered good-looking, tend to spend more time in jail, according to
various findings. Bloggers aren't sure what's odder--these conclusions,
or the way the Times doesn't interrogate them more.
- This Is a Little More Scientific Than It Sounds The Times piece points out that a number of subtly interrelated factors make this a murky question:
Linking physical traits to criminality may sound like a throwback to
the biological determinism advocated by 19th-century social Darwinists
who believed that there was a genetic predisposition for wrongdoing.
Practitioners are quick to distance themselves from such ideas. Mr.
Price, for example, argues that crime can be viewed, at least partly,
as an "alternative labor market." If individuals with certain physical
attributes are disadvantaged in the labor force, they may find crime
more attractive, he said.
- You Might Be Missing a Few Links At PrawfsBlawg, Bill Araiza
sees a complicated picture. "At first glance, I can't help but wonder
what in the world these researchers are thinking. The dynamics leading
from short stature or obesity seem obvious enough: childhood teasing,
non- or lesser participation in sports and other self-esteem building
activities, and a general sense of lesser desirability all lead to the
inculcation of attitudes that lead to conduct that leads to bad
outcomes. Or, simply enough, stature and weight turn on childhood
nutrition, which is significant in itself but may also be a marker for
how well the child is being cared for more generally ... Ultimately, I
think what's most interesting to me is the rather casual way in which
articles like the one in the Times mention these claims."
- Adjust Social Attitudes First At Shakesville, Melissa McEwan
rolls her eyes at the idea that being overweight is itself a surefire
criminal marker. "Sure, because if there is a correlation between fat
and criminality, it's definitely not the lifetime of being ostracized,
bullied, ignored, and/or denied equal pay and opportunities that
underlies the elevated potential for a fat person to commit crime, but
the fat itself. So we should definitely focus on eradicating fat,
rather than prejudice."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
aeichler at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.