Progressive Pillar Russ Feingold Crumbles in Wisconsin

John Hudson Nov 2, 2010

Russ Feingold, one of the Senate's most liberal members, has lost his Senate race in Wisconsin. A passionate opponent of the Patriot Act and champion of campaign finance reform, Feingold lost to Republican businessman Ron Johnson. Here's how pundits are explaining the loss:

  • Feingold Lost the Money Game  Ashby Jones at the Wall Street Journal writes:
...Johnson has invested more than $8 million of his money in the race, and although the two campaigns are competitive with each other financially, outside groups have spent nearly $3 million on Johnson’s behalf.

A WaPo analysis shows 92 percent of the outside spending has supported the Republican. The impact has been obvious: The Wesleyan Media Project said there have been more commercials about the Senate race in Wisconsin than in any state outside Nevada.

“I’ve always been a target in this stuff,” Feingold said during a recent campaign stop. “And this year, I’m getting the full dose: over $2 million in these ads [criticizing him] that used to not be legal.”

  • Or Maybe Johnson Had a Winning Message  Eric Kleefeld at Talking Points Memo writes: "So how did Johnson win? The biggest thing he did was campaign on not being a creature of Washington, a fresh face appealing to an atmosphere of anti-incumbency. As he explained in this ad, he's not a lawyer:"

  • Johnson Campaigned Against ObamaCare, writes Matthew Kaminski at The Wall Street Journal:

Ron Johnson beats Russ Feingold in Wisconsin, seemingly by double digits — even wider than the polls predicted. The president and first lady campaigned hard for the three-term Democratic incumbent. But Johnson, a political novice, ran a disciplined campaign. He made some gaffes and kept the press at a distance, but his direct manner and business career proved appealing. Johnson got his start by speaking up against ObamaCare at a Tea Party meeting last year, and made it a prominent part of his campaign. As one of his memorable television ads put it, Johnson will now be the sole manufacturer and second accountant in the Senate.

  • It's a Big Win for Conservatives, writes Frank James at NPR: "His defeat gives the Republicans one of their biggest political trophies of the evening since not only was he a liberal Democrat albeit with a renegade streak; he was also one-half of the hated (by Republicans) McCain-Feingold campaign finance law which many conservatives for years viewed as an abridgment of free speech rights and an anchor on Republican candidates."

If anyone should have been able to w/stand an anti-Washington wave, it was Feingold. Yet... #alwaysbepreparedless than a minute ago via web

K Powers makes point that Tea Party was regarded as a joke, but they've taken out Feingold: significant.less than a minute ago via web

russ feingold can guestblog anytime he wants #badconsolationprizebutbesticanofferless than a minute ago via TweetDeck

Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments or send an email to the author at jhudson at theatlantic dot com. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.

Sources

Related Articles   More by John Hudson

How Bill Clinton's Backroom Dealings in Florida Came to Be

Did Pennsylvania Senate Race Just Become a Toss-Up?

Parsing the Obama-Paterson Showdown

 

Norah O'Donnell: What I Read

R.J. Cutler: What I Read

Elsewhere on the Web

User Comments

Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register

  • The Atlantic Wire on Twitter
  • The Atlantic Wire RSS Feed
  • The Atlantic Wire iPhone App