P.T. Barnum was a pretty despicable character, Charles Baxter
finds in Lapham's Quarterly, but his influence was lasting. Reviewing
Barnum's autobiography, Baxter finds the seeds of the phenomenon of our
Mama Grizzly in Chief. "The Life of P. T. Barnum is one of those curious
historical artifacts: the sociopathic memoir," Baxter says--a book
recounting the many times Barnum conned the public in his "socially acceptable variety of sadism." Barnum
was apolitical, Baxter writes, but his modern imitators are not. This section comes at the end of a much longer essay. Have a look:
memoir feels like one of those postmodernist documents in which the
self is an empty category inhabiting an empire of signs without
substance, a superfluous text that has interest only when read against
itself. A rather dull and ill-written primer on selling shoddy
goods--though it sold 160,000 copies--its residual interest mostly resides
in the display of his brash showman's personality, an egg from which
many monsters have hatched. ...
Television, of course, is the playground
of present-day Barnum freaks, where plain citizens can be snatched out
of the crowd, put in the spotlight, and cued up to sing or dance, as in
American Idol. Self-destructive 'superstars' in the Andy Warhol sense
litter the pages of our weekly magazines addicted to celebrity. But
political advertisements, in particular, seem to be the new repository
of magical thinking. Candidates with little or no administrative
experience and no knowledge of facts on the ground (and who therefore
avoid 'mainstream' news conferences) are presented as brilliant problem
solvers or as saviors. You have to have nerves of steel, along with
steely Zen detachment, to avoid expectations aroused by contemporary
omnipresent, hyperinflated rhetoric. What are our political figures if
not openly show-business personalities? Who looks better on TV, Harry
Reid or Sarah Palin?
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
ereeve at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.