There is not always much to say in the face of a natural disaster and ensuing humanitarian crisis. But the earthquake in Haiti
seems to be different. Perhaps because of the severity
of the destruction, or because of the complex forces
that strain Haiti, or due simply to the commentary-rich nature of media
today, opinions on the quake are diverse and abundant. Many
writers are drawing wider conclusions about the world from the quake's
aftermath, touching on everything from China to the media. Here's what they've learned.
- Americans Aren't Very Generous The New York Times's Nicholas Kristof surveys
the annual per-capita donations to Haiti from various countries. One
might assume that the U.S., an immediate neighbor of Haiti with a large
Haitian population, would dominate the donations to Haiti. But it
doesn't, with Norway, Belgium, Luxembourg and others donating far more
on average. "Given the per capita sums, we have no right to be bragging
about our generosity in Haiti."
- Decline of Foreign News Coverage The American Prospect's Monica Potts laments
that the entirety of Western media has only one permanent Haiti
correspondent, an A.P. reporter, when it once had many. Potts says this
is symptomatic of shuttering foreign bureaus, with even giant
institutions like the New York Times now able to do little more than
aggregate anonymous Twitter feeds. "But the bigger tragedy is that
people are still clearly hungry for news
like this -- cable is full of Haiti coverage, with major
networks having expanded newscast hours -- and no one's there to provide
it to them," she writes. "Even institutions that have enough reporters
left don't have enough
money to invest in a reporter who can become ingrained in a faraway
- The Humanitarian Double Standard Media Matters's M.J. Rosenberg posits that the world only mobilizes for humanitarian crises that aren't man-made. "For
me, it's impossible to look at the horrific footage coming out of Haiti
and not think about Gaza. Especially when I see the faces of the
are scenes of horrific suffering. But
there are two significant differences.
The first is the scale of the suffering. The second is that the Haitian catastrophe is a natural disaster, which
humans could not prevent but are now trying to relieve. The suffering in Gaza is inflicted by
people, while other people look away."
- The Importance of Modern Transportation Galrahn of Information Dissemination explains
that Haiti's decrepit road system, its single-runway airport and its
damaged port have become the single biggest biggest challenges for
relief efforts in Haiti. USAID Chief "Rajiv Shah needs a logistics
expert - like yesterday, or he is going to have a real short term at
USAID," he writes. "The port issue will make or break the entire effort
in Haiti." If transportation within Haiti can't be established, "social
order is going to start breaking down over the next 48-72 hours.
Nineteen small Navy helicopters are not going to be able to meet the
demands of 3,000,000 people."
- China's Strength Is Exaggerated The Atlantic's James Fallows compares
Chinese and American relief efforts to Haiti, which demonstrate their
abilities. He quotes a reader who writes, "To me, this shows the still
enormous gulf in both power and the responsible use of power between
China and the U.S." Fallows concurs, citing, "The mismatch between
mainstream America's exaggerated sense of China's omni-competence --
eg, here* -- and the very uneven nature of Chinese development and prospects."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
mfisher at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.