Two weeks after the earthquake in Haiti, some wonder whether the heavy media presence in the country isn't doing more harm
than good. CNN
correspondent Sanjay Gupta's on-air treatment
of an injured girl has probably
occasioned more praise
, and more uneasy questions
, than any other news segment since
the disaster struck. But beyond Gupta, watchdogs have taken issue with the
tenor of coverage (including the still-prevalent use of the word "looting
"), the erosion of journalistic
neutrality, and the sheer number of reporters in a country straining to meet the needs of its citizens.
- Worse Than Underfoot Time's Jay Newton-Small, herself reporting from Haiti,
notes that news teams who distribute supplies can end up inciting a press of desperate people--a sight then beamed to audiences. "The longer the
tv crew remains the more violent the crowd gets: people are desperate especially
when they think they're vying for a few pieces of food or water that they may
not get if they're not out in front."
- Making Criminals Out of Victims At Tom Dispatch, Rebecca Solnit picks up the anti-"looting" cry
and demands that reporters stop seeing crime in the actions of every survivor.
"Those in power, those with guns and the force of law behind them, are too often
more concerned for property than human life. In an emergency, people can, and
do, die from those priorities. Or they get gunned down for minor thefts or
imagined thefts. The media not only endorses such outcomes, but regularly,
repeatedly, helps prepare the way for, and then eggs on, such a reaction."
- Everybody Into the
Pool Noam Scheiber at The New Republic frets that
"journalists must eat, drink, and circulate once they're in Haiti. As a
practical matter, it means they often end up mooching off supplies intended for
earthquake victims." Scheiber proposes a "disaster pool" to limit the number of correspondents saturating a troubled area: "The arrangement would obviously
be less than ideal for the outlets with the biggest budgets. But, collectively,
the media would have the peace of mind of knowing it's not exacerbating the same
problems it's trying to alleviate."
- Be One Thing or the Other Eric Deggans at the St. Petersburg Times
suggests that reporters like Gupta who want to do their part should leave their
day job at the door. "When you're a relief worker, be a relief worker 100
percent--don't have your camera crew taking pictures, don't interview anyone,
and don't use anything you witness in any news story. When you're done helping
deal with the crisis, put your reporter's hat on and rejoin the fray as a
Only We Can Do On The Huffington Post, Rob Crilly offers a defense of the fourth
estate, and some thoughts on its role in times of crisis. "My belief is that few
things benefit from less coverage. The job of a journalist is to bear witness,
to bring home stories of suffering so that the rest of the world cannot ignore
what is happening. My job is not to distribute food, water or medicine. My aid
comes in a different form."
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments
or send an email to the author at
aeichler at theatlantic dot com.
You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.