- It's Honest. In a short post, Mashable's Stan Schroeder offers his take: "The letter is a clear, sober, in-depth view in all of Flash's defects from Apple's point of view, and while we're sure it will be dissected over and over in the upcoming days (especially the part about Flash not being open), you have to admire its frankness." True to its name, Short Form Blog offers a short, but similar analysis: "We don't think Jobs has ever been this open. We'd like to see him keep this up in the future. It really makes his points seem reasonable." He then gives a "summary that's about a fifth of the size" of Jobs's original.
- This Matters Because It's Rare ZDNet's Andrew J. Nusca contextualizes the letter:
Jobs' letter is remarkable not for its argument, which has been elaborated on before by Apple and pundits alike, but in its very existence. It's highly unusual for the chief executive to respond to criticism in such a public and permanent way.
- Right On Daring Fireball's John Gruber, a popular Apple blogger, briefly praises the letter, calling it "cogent, detailed, straightforward. No prevarication. ... While you're reading it, think about how little wiggle room the whole thing leaves for Adobe to respond."
- Agreed: Flash 'Sucks' From John Biggs over at CrunchGear just plain doesn't like Flash:
So generally, Steve says Flash sucks and I tend to agree. Is it right that millions of Flash developers out there can't make their stuff in Flash for the iPad? Heck no. But is it right that I have to suffer painful rickets every time I visit a Flash site on my PC because of memory problems and poor programming? Probably not, either.
- Developers Won't Buy It Ars Technica's Jacqui Cheng doubts Apple's developers will fall in line:
Developers, on the other hand, aren't likely to be so willing to buy into Jobs' reasoning. After all, there are plenty of ways for developers to use cross-platform tools in order to create perfectly workable apps, HTML5 video doesn't necessarily guarantee better performance and battery life, and some Web developers will continue to create sites that are geared toward mice and not fingers.
Want to add to this story? Let us know in comments. You can share ideas for stories on the Open Wire.



User Comments
Please type your comment and click Post. If you’re not already logged in you will be prompted to log in or register